Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
We would like to acknowledge the support of the National Parkinson Foundation via a Center of Excellence award, the McKnight Brain Institute (Gainesville, FL), the University of Florida, Shands Hospital (Gainesville, FL), and the Eric and Jennifer Scott Fund for Parkinson’s Research (Gainesville, FL). Drs. Mustafa Siddiqui and Jessica Tate (Wake Forest School of Medicine) contributed significantly to this chapter in prior editions.
This chapter includes an accompanying lecture presentation that has been prepared by the authors: .
Movement disorders arise from basal ganglia dysfunction.
Patients with basal ganglia disorders often have nonmotor as well as motor manifestations of their disease. Identifying these greatly helps with diagnosis.
Characterization of a movement is algorithmic. A physician should sequentially define the region affected; whether the abnormal movement is fast, slow, or both; the movement’s regularity; its context; and whether it is voluntary.
Hyperkinetic disorders involve excess movement and include tremors, chorea, myoclonus, dyskinesia, tics, akathisia, and stereotypes.
Notable tremor disorders include essential tremor and parkinsonian tremor. Essential tremor usually begins bilaterally and is present during movement only. Parkinsonian tremor usually begins unilaterally and is initially present solely at rest.
Chorea is complex and continuous across multiple joints, whereas myoclonus involves simple and rapid contraction of a single muscle. Myoclonus can be distinguished from chorea based on the presence or absence of continuity across movements.
Notable choreas include Huntington disease and tardive chorea. These are differentiated by history and associated nonmotor features rather than appearance.
Myoclonus is most often encountered as one of a collection of symptoms rather than a primary manifestation.
Hypokinetic disorders involve reduced movement and include gait freezing, stiff person syndrome, and neuromyotonia.
Patients often report bradykinesia as a nonspecific feeling of fatigue. Examination will show slowing when attempting rapid movements such as finger tapping or foot stamping.
Dystonia involves simultaneous contraction of agonist/antagonist muscle pairings and can be brief or relatively sustained. The presence of a sensory trick and symptom relief with sleep are helpful in making the diagnosis.
Disorders of coordination present with poorly timed or aimed movements, potentially including speech. Any process affecting the cerebellum can result in discoordination.
Movement disorders caused by metabolic causes often have associated cognitive changes.
Unexplained movement disorders of rapid onset, particularly chorea or ataxia in the absence of a brain lesion, may be autoantibody-mediated paraneoplastic syndromes, warranting further work-up including antibody panels and imaging.
Movement disorders are a group of conditions that arise from functional aberrations in the motor and the nonmotor basal ganglia pathways. They are common and affect all age groups. A list of the most common movement disorders and their reported incidences are presented in Table 105.1 . The early signs and symptoms of movement disorders may be subtle and easily hidden by conscious or unconscious incorporation by the patient into common daily gestures. The key to diagnosing a movement disorder is careful study of its phenomenology, as well as its associated nonmotor features. In this chapter we provide an overview of movement disorders for practicing neurosurgeons, a topic also covered by other authors.
Syndrome | Prevalence (per 100,000) | Common Age Group |
---|---|---|
Parkinson disease | 295.6 | 60–70 |
Progressive supranuclear palsy | 0.4–6.4 | 60–70 |
Multiple system atrophy | 2.2–4.4 | 50–60 |
Essential tremor | 400–900 | >40 |
Huntington disease | 2–6.3 | <20 or >35 |
Tourette syndrome | 1850–2990 | <18 |
Cervical dystonia | 5.7–8.9 | 40 |
Restless legs syndrome | 4200–9800 | >45 |
Friedreich ataxia | 1.2–2 | 5–15 |
Patients with syndromes arising from dysfunction of the basal ganglia typically have a combination of motor and nonmotor manifestations. A thorough history and examination will avoid unnecessary tests and reduce subspecialty referrals. Once the history and general neurological examination have established the context for an abnormal movement, the movement should be characterized by visual inspection. Movements are classified on the basis of speed, anatomy, character, intentionality (i.e., voluntary, involuntary, or unvoluntary), triggers, and relieving factors.
First, the anatomic region involved should be defined. Focal disorders affect one region of the body, regional disorders affect two contiguous body parts, and generalized disorders affect both sides of the body or the axis, or both. Regarding a specific limb, the movement may be further classified as being proximal or distal. Next, the disorder should be characterized as hyperkinetic, hypokinetic, or mixed. Hyperkinetic disorders are typified by excessive movement (e.g., tremor), whereas hypokinetic disorders are typified by reduced movement (e.g., bradykinesia in Parkinson disease [PD]). The quality of the movement should also be described. Is the movement rhythmic, like a tremor, or jerky and irregular as in myoclonus? Does it alter when the patient is at rest , maintaining a posture , or performing an action ? Does it persist during sleep? Does the movement travel smoothly from body part to body part, as in chorea? Are opposing muscle groups cocontracting, as occurs in dystonia? Is it preceded by a premonitory urge and followed by a sense of relief, as with tics? Does the patient have difficulty with skilled movements, as in apraxia?
The patient should also be asked whether the movement is voluntary or involuntary. Movements may be referred to as “unvoluntary” when it is unclear which category applies. Triggers and relieving factors should be identified. Does the movement worsen with action, or is it relieved? Do particular positions precipitate the abnormality? Is there specific sensory input that relieves the symptoms?
Finally, the presence of specific nonmotor symptoms can lead the clinician to the proper diagnosis. Table 105.2 lists common features of movement disorders and the specific diagnoses that they may suggest.
Features | Categories | Examples of Specific Syndromes |
---|---|---|
Speed | Hyperkinetic | Tremor, chorea, myoclonus, tics, restless legs syndrome |
Hypokinetic | Apraxia, blocking tics, parkinsonism: bradykinesia, primary progressive freezing of gait | |
Region | Whole body | Hyperekplexia, generalized dystonia |
Hemibody | Hemiparkinsonism, hemidystonia | |
Segmental | Segmental myoclonus | |
Multifocal | Polyminimyoclonus | |
Focal | Writer’s cramp | |
Proximal | Rubral tremor | |
Distal | Painful legs when moving toes | |
Oral | Tardive dyskinesia, neuroacanthocytosis | |
Character | Rhythm | Rhythmic: Parkinson disease, essential tremor |
Arrhythmic: myoclonus, dystonic tremor | ||
Frequency | Faster: essential tremor, orthostatic tremor | |
Slower: rubral tremor | ||
Amplitude | Large: essential tremor, rubral tremor | |
Fine: orthostatic tremor, physiologic tremor | ||
At rest | Parkinsonism: tremor | |
During posture | Physiologic tremor, drug-induced tremor, essential tremor, some cerebellar and dystonia tremors | |
With action | Cerebellar tremor, essential tremor, dystonic tremor | |
Accompaniment | Tics: premonitory urge | |
Intentionality | Voluntary | Tics |
Involuntary | Tardive dyskinesia, stereotypies, tics | |
Unvoluntary | Tic disorders | |
Triggers | Action | Musician’s dystonia |
Position | Orthostatic tremor | |
Sensory stimulation | Catalepsy, hyperekplexia, stimulus-sensitive myoclonus | |
Relieving factors | Sleep | Improves: dystonia, tremor, not essential palatal tremor |
Sensory tricks (gestes antagonistes) | Improves: dystonia | |
Nonmotor features | Autonomic | Multiple system atrophy: orthostasis, parkinsonism: drooling |
Psychiatric | Huntington disease, Parkinson disease: depression |
In tremor a body part oscillates rhythmically about a set point. The tremor may be regular or irregular, unilateral or bilateral, and symmetrical or asymmetrical, and may present in one or several body regions. The frequency and amplitude of a tremor depend heavily on its underlying cause.
Tremor is classified according to its appearance or its cause. , If the tremor occurs during movement, it is referred to as action or kinetic tremor. A tremor occurring in the absence of activity is classified as rest tremor. Postural tremor manifests when a specific position is maintained (e.g., holding the arm extended). Finally, physiologic tremor is the term applied to nonpathologic postural tremor, which typically has a frequency of 8 to 12 Hz. Drug-induced tremors are usually due to an enhancement of physiologic tremor.
Tremor may be triggered by synchronized oscillatory signals arising from one of several locations. These signals may originate centrally, from circuits in either the basal ganglia or cerebellum that are involved in sensorimotor integration, motor timing, muscle coordination, or sympathetic control. One common example of centrally driven tremor is essential tremor (ET). ET has been ascribed to overactive central oscillators in the thalamus , and to thalamocortical loop overactivity. In contrast, cerebellar and rubral tremors, which may occur after stroke or traumatic brain injury, are thought to result from motor dysregulation (i.e., from unbalanced feed-forward or feedback systems, or from both).
Weighting a tremoring limb can help determine whether the tremor is physiologic or a pathologic tremor of central origin. Tremors predominantly of central origin will decrease in frequency when loaded, whereas the 8- to 12-Hz oscillation of physiologic tremor typically does not.
Although it can be difficult to differentiate among subtypes of tremor solely on the basis of their frequency, it may be helpful to note that tremors of the hands greater than 11 Hz or less than 6 Hz are almost always pathologic. Pathologic tremors also seem to have a “floor” frequency. PD tremor and ET are among the lower frequency tremors and typically do not oscillate at less than 4 Hz. Tremors with frequencies in this range are usually due to malfunction of the brainstem or cerebellum. The frequency of a tremor may decrease slightly over time, in one series by approximately 2 to 3 Hz over a period of 4 to 8 years. This small degree of change does not usually lead to diagnostic confusion.
Amplitude cannot be used effectively to differentiate tremor types because it may vary widely within a particular tremor subtype. In general, tremor subtypes with the lowest frequency can be expected to have the highest amplitude and vice versa, but this rule is not absolute. Emotional distress, exercise, and fatigue may exacerbate tremors of any subtype. Stressors tend to increase the amplitude of a tremor but have less effect on tremor frequency.
Common tremor conditions include ET, PD, dystonic tremor, cerebellar/outflow tremor, Holmes tremor, physiologic tremor, palatal tremor, neuropathic tremor, drug- or toxin-induced tremor, task-specific tremor, primary writing tremor (PWT), and psychogenic tremor. The characteristics of these tremors are presented in Table 105.3 . , ,
Tremor Disorder | Rest | Postural | Action | Frequency | Average Age at Onset | Family History | Features |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cerebellar tremor | − | + | +++ | 2–5 Hz | Variable | Variable | May be severe with action |
Drug-induced tremor | +/− | ++ | + | Variable | None | Improves with drug discontinuation | |
Dystonic tremor | + | ++ | ++ | Irregular, 3–8 Hz | Adulthood | Variable | Irregular |
Essential tremor | + | ++ | +++ | 6–8 or 8–12 Hz | Early adult | Common | Usually slightly asymmetrical, involves the hands most commonly |
Orthostatic tremor | − | ++ | − | 10 or 14–16 Hz | Late | Rare | Occurs only on standing still |
Palatal tremor | ++ | − | ++ | 1–4 Hz | Variable | Rare | EPT may be accompanied by a click; SPT may persist in sleep |
PD tremor | +++ | + | +/− | 4–9 Hz | Middle age | Occasional | Variable in appearance; improves with levodopa in 60% of individuals |
Physiologic tremor | − | ++ | + | 8–12 Hz | Childhood | Common | Present in all individuals |
Posttraumatic tremor | +/− | ++ | ++ | Variable | None | Appearance varies with the site of trauma; myoclonus is frequently present | |
Rubral tremor | ++ | +++ | +++ | 2–5 Hz | Variable | None | Large amplitude |
Task-specific tremor | – | – | ++ | 4–7 Hz | Adulthood | Occasional | Tremor with task or task-associated position |
Physiologic tremor is a term applied to the 8- to 12-Hz tremor seen in any healthy person who is intentionally sustaining a posture. More proximal regions of the body oscillate at a lower frequency, more distal ones at a higher frequency. For example, physiologic tremor has a frequency of 3 to 5 Hz at the elbow, whereas metacarpophalangeal tremor usually ranges from 17 to 30 Hz. When this tremor impairs motor performance, it is referred to as enhanced physiologic tremor .
Physiologic tremor is typically symmetrical. As with other tremor types, the amplitude is reported to decrease with age, particularly after the age of 50, , although some authors have found otherwise. Age has not been shown to affect the frequency of physiologic tremor. ,
It is unclear whether mild forms of the syndrome can be distinguished from ET. Both ET and physiologic tremor can be elicited by posture, both are fairly symmetrical, and both occur predominantly in the arms. Observing the progression of a tremor over time will eventually reveal whether a given patient has ET or physiologic tremor.
ET is the most common tremor disorder, with an overall prevalence of 0.4% to 0.9%. In people older than 60, it can be as high as 4.6%. It generally manifests as a low-amplitude, bilateral action and postural tremor with a frequency of 6 to 8 Hz. The tremor usually has its onset in adulthood and worsens over time, but it may begin in childhood and can coexist with other movement disorders. The overall prevalence of ET is similar between genders, although women with ET seem to be more prone to head tremor than men.
ET involves the upper limbs in more than 90% of patients. It less commonly involves the head, legs, or voice. It rarely affects the face or trunk. ET often has a postural component that may be reported as a rest tremor by patients. Although some rest tremor can be seen in advanced ET, an action tremor should clearly dominate. Patients commonly first complain of difficulty with tasks requiring fine coordination, such as threading a needle, tying knots, or writing. Later, more gross activities are also affected. In severe cases, basic activities of daily living may become impossible to perform.
Cognitive dysfunction and gait abnormalities may also be features of ET. Set shifting, verbal fluency, and other frontal cortex functions are impaired in patients with ET relative to age-matched controls. This cognitive impairment does not correlate with tremor severity.
Several features of ET point to an underlying cerebellar or brainstem pathology. Patients with ET frequently have an end point tremor and difficulty with tandem gait. Researchers have described subclinical eye movement abnormalities indicative of cerebellar dysfunction. There are case reports of ipsilateral improvement in symptoms after cerebellar infarction, and inducing lesions of the cerebellothalamic receiving area (the ventral intermediate nucleus of the thalamus) is an effective treatment of ET. Although positron emission tomography has shown increased olivary glucose utilization and cerebellar blood flow, the brains of ET patients appear to be structurally normal. Postmortem studies by Louis and colleagues suggested a cerebellar variant with Purkinje cell loss, axonal torpedoes, basket cell changes, and a Lewy body variant with increased Lewy bodies in the brainstem. The evidence for cerebellar Purkinje cell dysfunction is mixed; in a case-control study of ET, Rajput and colleagues did not find Purkinje cell loss.
A family history of tremor is common in patients in whom ET is diagnosed. A positive family history has been reported in as many as 96% of patients and as few as 17%, depending on the sample. A survey of New York City residents showed a 5- to 10-fold increase in risk for ET in first-degree relatives, as well as an increase in the likelihood of ET developing in family members with earlier onset of symptoms in the patient.
Several inherited forms of ET have been identified, including the gene loci EMT1 (on chromosome 3q13) and EMT2 (on 2p24) and an unnamed gene locus on 6p23. , ET has been reported in fragile X syndrome, Kennedy syndrome, XXYY syndrome, and Klinefelter syndrome. , Sex chromosome–related tremors often have associated ataxia and may represent a separate tremor type.
The presence of a rest tremor in a patient who otherwise meets the criteria for ET can be confusing. Current opinion among movement disorder neurologists favors the diagnosis of ET when the action and postural components of a tremor greatly outweigh the rest component and the rest component is bilateral. New-onset unilateral rest tremor should always bring PD to mind. Although isolated head tremor is often diagnosed as ET, if upper extremity tremor is absent, it is more likely to be dystonic tremor.
The question of whether ET predisposes patients to the later development of PD is also a perplexing one. There are some cases in which families appear to be prone to both PD and ET. Jankovic’s group reported that the same locus yielded pure ET and ET-PD-dystonia in different families. As of this writing, the exact association between ET and PD remains a topic of discussion.
The tremor of PD was described by James Parkinson in 1817 in his historic Essay on the Shaking Palsy and was further characterized by Charcot in the 1860s in his lectures at the Salpetriere. PD tremor is a 4- to 9-Hz low-amplitude rest tremor. The tremor often has a prominent proximal thumb component that gives it a “pill-rolling” quality. The presence of a pill-rolling tremor is not diagnostic.
Although there is some thought that PD tremor may dampen or “burn out” over time, others have observed the opposite. Parkinson himself wrote that “as the debility increases … the tremulous agitation becomes more vehement [and] the motion becomes so violent as not only to shake the bed-hangings, but even the floor and sashes of the room.”
Unlike typical ET, PD hand tremor may worsen in the ipsilateral lower limb before affecting the contralateral hand. A typical pattern of spread is for a hand to be affected first, followed by the ipsilateral foot and then the contralateral hand. Although different extremities exhibit the same frequency of tremor, they need not shake simultaneously. When tremor is bilateral in onset without involving the legs, causes other than PD should be considered. PD tremor is frequently intermittent and typically becomes more pronounced with distraction.
Reemergent tremor occurs while sustaining a prolonged position and most likely represents a rest tremor that has been reset by the relative stasis of a persistent position. Postural tremor was seen in two-thirds of patients with PD in one case series, and correlates with the degree of functional disability.
The pathogenesis of PD tremor is not well understood. In monkeys with 1 -methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP)–induced parkinsonism, basal ganglia neurons begin to fire synchronously. Some authors have suggested that PD tremor originates from loss of segregation of these information channels and subsequent synchronization of adjacent circuits. Loss of dopamine in the basal ganglia may unmask pacemaker-like properties of the basal ganglia. It should be noted that the severity of PD tremor does not correlate with the severity of dopamine neuronal loss and that treatment with levodopa improves bradykinesia and rigidity more reliably than it does tremor.
The central origin of PD tremor is demonstrated by the observation that afferent denervation affects the amplitude and frequency of the tremor but does not abolish it.
Cerebellar tremor can be characterized as a jerky, low-frequency (2 to 4 Hz), high-amplitude action tremor. This tremor may be accompanied by other cerebellar signs such as ataxia, dysdiadochokinesia, dysarthria, dysmetria, and telegraphic speech. The normal pattern of cerebellar ballistic control, as described by Hallett and associates, consists of sequential agonist-antagonist–second agonist activation.
Patients with lesions in the region of the red nucleus may be predisposed to the development of what is referred to as a rubral tremor, first described by Holmes in 1904. Although predominantly an action tremor, rubral tremor frequently has a significant resting component. The amplitude of movement tends to be large and it can sometimes adopt a “wing-beating” appearance. Rubral tremors are among the slowest tremors, with frequencies often less than 4 Hz.
As with cerebellar and symptomatic palatal tremor (SPT), rubral tremor arises from damage to the cerebellar and brainstem motor pathways and from dysregulation of motor control during movement.
The motor coordination control centers and their connections are situated deep in the brain, and to damage them generally requires substantial injury. Consequently, posttraumatic tremor is rarely an isolated finding. The character of the tremor depends on the region of the brain that is damaged. Damage to the brainstem may produce rest tremor if it affects the substantia nigra and related pathways. Damage to the cerebellum may result in a low-frequency action tremor. Because multiple regions are usually damaged, posttraumatic tremors are generally mixed in character. In one series of severe posttraumatic tremors, all patients displayed both action and postural tremors, whereas rest tremor was seen in just 56% of cases. Posttraumatic tremor is often accompanied by myoclonus. As noted by Obeso and Narbona, this apparent myoclonus appears in some cases to be an exaggeration of a beat of the ongoing tremor rather than true myoclonus.
Drug-induced tremors are united by a common cause rather than a common appearance. Usually, drug-induced tremors have a higher frequency and involve limbs symmetrically, although lower frequency tremors are also seen. The onset of tremor should be temporally related to drug ingestion.
Drugs most commonly associated with tremor include alcohol, amiodarone, antidepressants, antiepileptic medications, beta-agonist bronchodilators, caffeine, immunosuppressive agents, lithium, neuroleptics, nicotine, steroids, and sympathomimetics. Alcohol intoxication (acute or chronic) and immunosuppressive agents may produce cerebellar tremors. Sympathomimetics, serotonin reuptake inhibitors, nicotine, and other centrally acting agents typically produce an enhanced physiologic tremor. Because the physiologic effects of an offending drug are rarely limited to tremor, the causative agent may also be recognized by associated nonneurological symptoms.
There are numerous less commonly encountered tremor types that one must consider in the differential diagnosis of tremor.
Orthostatic tremor is a syndrome characterized by trembling of the legs and an intense feeling of unsteadiness that occurs on standing upright. The symptoms are relieved by walking or sitting down. , Orthostatic tremor was first described by Heilman in 1984. The tremor is typically of low amplitude and is present predominantly in the legs. It is less frequently observed in the face, arms, or trunk. Surface electromyography (EMG) reveals a pathognomonic pattern of a 13- to 18-Hz tremor when the patient stands upright. When other body parts are affected, the tremor occurs at the same frequency as in the legs. Orthostatic tremor in the arms may be become evident if the patient is examined while on all fours. Given the high frequency and low amplitude of the tremor, it may be difficult to appreciate and may appear as little more than a subtle quivering.
Impairment of balance and increased swaying are well-described features of the syndrome. They may result from disrupted sensory feedback or from the disruption of motor regulation at the muscular level.
Orthostatic tremor’s underlying pathology remains unknown. The tremor is not solely brought on by load bearing; even when the load on the legs is reduced by suspending patients in the upright position, the tremor pattern remains stable.
Palatal tremor consists of a steady and constant-amplitude oscillation of either the tensor veli palatini or the levator veli palatini muscles. Palatal tremor is also referred to as palatal myoclonus ; however, most authors now classify it as a tremor syndrome.
Palatal tremor may be divided into symptomatic palatal tremor (SPT) and essential palatal tremor (EPT). EPT is characterized by a slow (2 Hz) rhythmic elevation of the soft palate because of contraction of the tensor veli palatini muscle. A typical initial complaint is a clicking noise heard in one ear; the tensor inserts at the eustachian tube, and as the muscle contracts, the tube opens and closes, which causes a clicking noise.
Patients with SPT have the same slow and rhythmic movement of the soft palate as do patients with EPT. Unlike EPT, however, in SPT the movement is thought to be due to contraction of the levator veli palatini muscle and thus is not typically associated with an ear click. In 30% of patients with SPT the tremor is accompanied by rotatory or vertical pendular nystagmus. SPT is thought to arise from damage to the area bounded by the red nucleus, the inferior olive, and the dentate nucleus (the Guillain-Mollaret triangle). This results in autonomous firing of the inferior olive. Postmortem analysis of the ipsilateral inferior olive has provided further evidence of an olivary origin for SPT: pathologic examination reveals hypertrophic degeneration and enlarged neurons with cytoplasmic vacuolization. SPT is difficult to modify and is unusual among the hyperkinesias in that it persists even in sleep.
EPT is distinguished from SPT by the presence of an ear click, relief during sleep, and an absence of structural brainstem pathology. Some authors report that EPT predominantly involves the roof of the palate’, whereas in SPT the contraction is more notable at the palatal verge.
When the cause of a tremor is psychogenic, the symptoms may vary from moment to moment in their frequency, amplitude, direction, or location. Symptoms may disappear with distraction or on subsequent examinations. For this reason, it is often helpful to perform serial videotaped examinations.
Although psychogenic tremors may affect any part of the body, they most frequently involve the head, arms, and legs. The tremor tends to shift from region to region even as it alters in its other characteristics. They may disappear with distraction. Most patients display rest, postural, and action tremor to a varying degree. Symptoms may appear suddenly, with quick evolution to large amplitudes. Other clues to a psychogenic origin include entrainment and active resistance to passive range of motion. Entrainment occurs when a tremor’s frequency shifts to match that of a voluntary repetitive movement of another body part. Entrainment may be enhanced by distracting the patient. Psychogenic tremor may also respond paradoxically to loading, which increases rather than decreases the tremor in frequency and amplitude.
Psychogenic tremor can be difficult to distinguish from tremor of other causes. Deuschl and colleagues reported a case of psychogenic palatal tremor in which the patient duplicated the typical clicking movements of that disorder by repetitively clapping his soft palate against his pharynx.
A psychogenic origin of a movement disorder should be considered whenever there are obvious incongruities in a patient’s signs and symptoms. Resolution after suggestion or administration of placebo, distractibility, coexisting psychiatric disorders, or inconsistency of symptoms over time should all raise clinicians’ suspicion.
Deuschl and coworkers proposed that cocontraction of antagonist muscle groups is a necessary condition for psychogenic tremor. Patients with hand tremor of psychogenic origin tend to show EMG coactivation in the finger flexors and extensors shortly before onset of the tremor.
The label task-specific tremor applies, as might be expected, to any tremor brought on by performing a particular set of actions. Onset occurs in adulthood.
Primary writing tremor (PWT) is the stereotypical task-specific tremor: a unilateral action tremor of 4 to 7 Hz that occurs during the act of writing or while adopting the posture associated with that act. The task specificity of PWT suggests a central cause, as does report of successful treatment by deep brain stimulation.
Some authors have classified task-specific tremor as a form of ET, and some as being related to task-specific dystonia, whereas others believe it to be a distinct nosologic entity. Like dystonia, task-specific tremor is asymmetrical and triggered by a task. Both sometimes respond to anticholinergic therapy. Generalized dystonia and PWT have been found to cluster within certain kindreds.
PWT and writer’s cramp may be distinguished on the basis of differential reciprocal muscle inhibition. Patients with writer’s cramp usually display forearm reciprocal muscle inhibition on EMG, whereas patients with PWT do not.
Regardless of whether PWT is truly a form of dystonia, the two occur together often enough that patients with task-specific tremor should also be examined for signs of dystonia. Actions other than writing have also been associated with task-specific tremor. For example, task-related chin tremor has been reported.
Dystonic tremor is a jerky postural and action tremor that is abolished by complete rest and occurs in a body part affected by dystonia. Its amplitude tends to be irregular, and it tends to have a variable frequency. Dystonic tremors usually oscillate at frequencies of 7 Hz or less. The amplitude of the movements can often be reduced if patients touch a particular part of their body (i.e., a geste antagoniste or “sensory trick”).
The mechanism of dystonic tremor differs from that of ET and PD. Dystonic tremor arises from unequally affected agonist-antagonist muscles rather than the dysfunctional CNS oscillator of ET and PD. Dystonic tremor of the neck can be distinguished from the head tremor of ET by dystonic head tremor’s irregular amplitude, relief by sensory tricks, and head greater than hand involvement. Physicians should also be careful to look for relief with sensory tricks and for dystonia in other parts of the body.
Other features of dystonia are discussed more fully in the section on dystonia.
Chorea consists of random and complex involuntary movements that flit from body part to body part. Chorea travels across multiple contiguous joints and often resembles exaggerated fidgetiness. The movements can be focal or generalized and are usually absent during sleep. The word chorea is derived from the Greek khoreia or “to dance.” Chorea may be among the first defined movement disorders. Chorea Sancti Viti (St. Vitus dance) was described in the Middle Ages. It was one term among several (St. John’s dance, tarantism) used to refer to the independent outbreaks of “dancing mania” that occurred in central Europe, most notably around the time of the plague. “St. Vitus dance” is now used predominantly to refer to Sydenham chorea. Choreas can be further classified by their appearance. Athetosis refers to a slow, sinuous, undulating movement, usually of the hands or feet. Sudden and large-amplitude movements are referred to as ballistic, derived from the Greek word meaning “to throw.”
Multiple chorea syndromes have been described ( Table 105.4 ), including Huntington chorea, Sydenham chorea, Wilson disease, neuroacanthocytosis, Friedreich ataxia, dentatorubral-pallidoluysian atrophy (DRPLA), McLeod syndrome, benign hereditary chorea (BHC), spinocerebellar ataxia (SCA types 2, 3, or 17), chorea gravidarum, drug-induced chorea, metabolic chorea (i.e., secondary to accumulation of toxins or liver, kidney, endocrine disease, or paraneoplastic autoimmunogenicity), tardive dyskinesia, paraneoplastic chorea, polycythemia vera, and psychogenic chorea.
Genetic Chorea Syndromes | Gene (Chromosome) a | Gene Defect (Symptomatic Range) | Protein Product | Age at Onset | Inheritance |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Benign hereditary chorea | TITF1 (14q) | Variable | Thyroid transcription factor-1 | <5 | Autosomal dominant |
DRPLA | ATN1 (12p12) | CAG repeat (>49) | Atrophin-1 | <20 or >40 | Autosomal dominant |
Huntington chorea | IT15 /HD (4p16) | CAG repeat (>35) | Huntingtin | <20 (juvenile) or 35–50 | Autosomal dominant |
HDL1 | PRNP (20p12) | Octapeptide repeat | Prion protein | 20–40 | Autosomal dominant |
HDL2 | JPH3 (16q24) | CTG-CAG repeat (>44) | Junctophilin-3 | 25–45 | Autosomal dominant |
HDL3 | (4p15) | Unknown | Unknown | 3–4 | Autosomal recessive |
HDL4/SCA17 | TBP (6q27) | CAA-CAG repeat (>42) | TATA-box binding protein | 25–40 | Autosomal dominant |
Neuroferritinopathy | FTL (19q13) | Variable | Ferritin light-chain polypeptide | 40 | Autosomal dominant |
Choreoacanthocytosis | CHAC/VPS13A (9q21) | Variable | Chorein | 20–30 | Autosomal recessive |
McLeod syndrome | XK (Xp21) | Variable | Xk antigen | 40–60 | X-linked recessive |
PKAN/NBIA | PANK2 (20p13) | Variable | Pantothenate kinase-2 | 3–5 | Autosomal recessive |
Wilson disease | ATP7B (13q14) | Variable | ATP7B protein | 20–30 | Autosomal recessive |
PKD | EKD2 (16q13) | Variable | Unknown | 10–20 | Autosomal dominant (25% sporadic) |
PNKD | MR1 , FPD (2q34) | Variable | Unknown | 5–20 | Autosomal dominant |
a These gene and chromosome linkages were identified in smaller cohorts. Other genes may be implicated in a given individual.
Huntington disease (HD) is the most common form of inherited chorea. Symptoms usually begin during the third to fifth decades of life. Although chorea is the most common initial symptom, unsteadiness of gait, dystonia, myoclonus, loss of bulbar control, and cognitive changes also occur and may appear before chorea does. Bradykinesia usually develops as the disease progresses, but it may be underappreciated in the presence of more obvious symptoms.
The chorea of HD is typically symmetrical and tends to increase in amplitude over time. The first manifestation of chorea may be a slight flicking of the fingers seen while walking. Patients are frequently unaware of their movements and may continue to treat their gyrations with indifference, even when made aware of them. Early symptoms include an impairment of rapid saccades, , psychiatric and mood changes, and tics. Ataxia is unusual and should raise concern for another syndrome, such as neuroacanthocytosis, SCA, or Friedreich ataxia.
Impersistence of movement is a classic feature of HD. Patients typically have difficulty maintaining tongue protrusion. They also tend to have difficulty keeping their gaze fixed on an object. Paradoxically, they may have trouble switching their attention from the examiner’s face. This has been referred to as a visual grasp reflex and is not specific for HD.
HD is defined as being of juvenile onset if symptoms occur by the age of 20. It is more often associated with stiffness, eye movement difficulties, and bradykinesia than adult-onset HD is. Seizures are also more frequent in juvenile-onset HD. Adult-onset HD occasionally manifests as this phenotype.
The cognitive and behavioral features of HD are both prominent and disabling. Many features are similar to those seen after frontal lobe damage. Grasp, snout, and other primitive reflexes may be prominent. Scores on psychomotor tests such as the Trail Making Test B and Stroop interference test show declines earlier in the course of HD than do tests of memory. Worsening scores correlate with the degree of striatal atrophy present. Dementia occurs in the majority of patients, although exceptions may occur when the chorea is of late onset. Other psychiatric symptoms include apathy, depression, lability, impulsivity, outbursts of anger, mania, and paranoia. , Physicians should always inquire about substance abuse and suicidality.
The genetic defect responsible for HD is a CAG repeat on chromosome 4 in a region that encodes the protein huntingtin, whose function is unknown. The number of copies of this repeat determines the presence or absence of clinical HD; patients with 29 to 35 repeats are expected to be asymptomatic. , The number of CAG repeats may increase in transmission and result in anticipation : earlier onset and increasing severity in successive generations. Paternal inheritance of HD has been correlated with a higher number of triplet repeats in the next generation, , probably because of gene expansion during spermatogenesis. An increased number of triplet repeats correlates with both earlier disease onset and the degree of functional decline.
The diagnosis of HD is based on clinical features and confirmed by genetic testing for the huntingtin gene. Caudate atrophy, characterized by “boxing” of lateral ventricles best seen with coronal brain imaging, is the classic finding on imaging studies. Frontal lobe atrophy is also seen. Imaging changes predate clinical diagnosis, and correlate in degree with symptom severity. Physicians may encounter the HD phenotype in the absence of the HD genotype. In one large series, approximately 7% of patients displaying the HD phenotype proved not to have a mutation in the huntingtin gene.
Four Huntington disease–like (HDL) syndromes have been identified. All are rare. HDL1 is an inherited prion disorder. HDL2 is caused by a CAG/CTG expansion in the junctophilin-3 protein and is more common in patients of African, Mexican, Spanish, or Portuguese descent. HDL2 is the most HD-like of the HDLs in its symptomatology. It may be accompanied by erythrocyte acanthocytosis. An early childhood–onset HDL variant, HDL3, has been identified in isolated cohorts. Its genetic basis remains unknown. HDL4 is synonymous with SCA type 17 (SCA17). SCA17 has a variety of phenotypes, one of which closely mimics the symptoms of HD. HDL4 arises from a CAA-CAG repeat in chromosome 6.
Sydenham chorea is a delayed complication of infection with group A β-hemolytic streptococci that usually develops 4 to 8 weeks after the infection, but it may develop as long as 6 months afterward. Sydenham chorea may be the sole manifestation of rheumatic fever in as many as 20% of patients , and remains the most common cause of acute childhood chorea in the world.
The typical age at onset of Sydenham chorea is 8 to 9 years; it is rarely seen in children younger than 5 years. , The chorea usually generalizes but there are exceptions, and 20% of patients remain hemichoreic. Sydenham chorea may be accompanied by tics and psychiatric symptoms. Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) occur in 20% to 30% of patients and may precede or follow the onset of chorea. The disease is self-limited and spontaneously remits after 8 to 9 months in a large percentage of patients, but up to 50% may still have chorea 2 years after infection.
Antineuronal antibodies are present in a majority of patients with Sydenham chorea. Antistreptolysin (ASO) titers are typically elevated but are nonspecific for infection with group A streptococci; this test is not useful in diagnosing Sydenham chorea. However, elevated ASO titers may be of help in distinguishing a recurrence of Sydenham chorea from a chorea from some other cause. , MRI in patients with Sydenham chorea has been reported to show transient swelling in the striatum and globus pallidus and increased signal intensity on T2-weighted images. ,
Tardive dyskinesia results from treatment with dopamine receptor blocking agents. Tardive syndromes are less frequently caused by atypical (e.g., clozapine, quetiapine) than by typical (e.g., haloperidol) neuroleptics. Dopamine-depleting medications have not been definitively associated with tardive dyskinesia. Some common antiemetics (e.g., metoclopramide) and some antitussives (e.g., promethazine [Phenergan]) are dopaminergic blockers whose use may lead to the development of tardive movements.
The most common pattern of tardive dyskinesia is stereotyped and repetitive movement of the face. Tongue-thrusting and involuntary chewing movements reminiscent of those seen in choreoacanthocytosis may be seen. Tardive dyskinesia is often accompanied by a feeling of restlessness, referred to as akathisia. This may be localized and reported as a “burning” sensation, often of the genitals or mouth.
Although tardive chorea has been reported after treatment with atypical antipsychotics, it occurs infrequently in this setting. Of the neuroleptics, clozapine appears least likely to induce tardive disorders. Large clinical trials have recently suggested that although atypical antipsychotics produce tardive dyskinesia less often than first-generation antipsychotics do, the difference may not be as great as was thought. ,
BHC is a slowly progressive childhood-onset chorea that is not associated with worsening dementia. The lack of cognitive worsening and early chorea differentiate it from juvenile HD. Onset most commonly occurs at 1 year of age, and symptoms may improve during adolescence.
BHC is heterogeneous in its manifestations and may be associated with myoclonus, dystonia, dysarthria, and gait difficulties. This led to some doubt regarding whether it truly represented a separate disorder until the discovery that a number of families with BHC possessed mutations in the gene encoding thyroid transcription factor 1 (TITF1). Defects in TITF1 have also been tied to a disorder consisting of chorea, congenital hypothyroidism, and pulmonary dysfunction, or “brain-thyroid-lung syndrome” (BTLS). Although BTLS has been differentiated from “classic” BHC, BHC and BTLS may represent two points on the same clinical spectrum. It can also be difficult to distinguish BHC and essential myoclonus. Both syndromes have comparable ages at onset and similar appearances. Features that vary between the two include gait involvement and improvement with alcohol. Gait involvement is common in BHC but rare in essential myoclonus. Improvement with alcohol ingestion is common in essential myoclonus but rare in BHC.
Two diseases fall under the rubric of neuroacanthocytosis: choreoacanthocytosis and McLeod syndrome. Both are characterized by acanthocytes on peripheral smear, peripheral neuropathy, psychiatric symptoms, and seizures. Serum creatinine kinase may be mildly elevated in either syndrome.
Choreoacanthocytosis is an autosomal recessive disease with an age at onset of 20 to 40 years. Orofacial dystonia is one of the characteristic features of the disease, and it typically manifests as lip and tongue biting. Patients may involuntarily push food out of the mouths with the tongue when eating (“eating dystonia”). Generalized chorea, dystonia, and tics can also occur. Abnormalities of saccadic eye movement may develop, similar to those in HD. Unlike HD, peripheral neuropathy is typically present. A finding of areflexia with orolingual dystonia is highly suggestive of this syndrome. Choreoacanthocytosis is associated with mutations in the chorea acanthocytosis (CHAC) gene, which encodes a protein designated chorein.
McLeod syndrome is a rare X-linked acanthocytic disease caused by defects in a gene responsible for erythrocyte antigens. The mean age at the onset of CNS symptoms is 40 years, and they may lag behind the hematologic diagnosis by decades. Symptoms of McLeod syndrome include chorea, cognitive decline, paranoia, psychosis and limb weakness. Atrophy is neurogenic and seen predominantly in the distal ends of the lower limbs. Case series suggest that unlike autosomal recessive choreoacanthocytosis, involuntary lip and tongue biting occurs in only a minority of patients. In addition to CNS symptoms, cardiomyopathy, arrhythmias, and hemolytic anemia may develop.
DRPLA produces a combination of chorea and ataxia and is named for the pattern of atrophy of the dentatofugal and pallidofugal pathways often seen in this syndrome. It occurs most commonly in Japan, although variant forms have been reported in the United States. ,
DRPLA, like HD, is an autosomal dominant triplet repeat disease. Also as in HD, successive generations of persons with DRPLA tend to have an earlier age at onset. This acceleration is more rapid with paternal transmission. There are five cardinal features of the syndrome: cerebellar ataxia, dementia or mental retardation, chorea, seizures, and myoclonus.
DRPLA may be divided primarily into juvenile- and adult-onset variants. The symptoms of juvenile-onset DRPLA often lead physicians to initially diagnose progressive myoclonic epilepsy because myoclonus and seizures are the predominant symptoms. Adult-onset DRPLA is characterized by chorea, ataxia, psychosis, and dementia. The dementia in adult-onset DRPLA is usually milder than that in juvenile-onset cases.
An adult-onset variant of DRPLA has been found in an African American family living near North Carolina’s Haw River. The Haw River variant displays a number of differences from other DRPLA variants: microcalcification of the basal ganglia, demyelination of the centrum semiovale, atrophy of the posterior column, and prominent paranoia, delusions, and hallucinations. Although generalized tonic seizures are common in this cohort, they are not myoclonic.
Pathologic findings in DRPLA include a small (but not necessarily atrophic) brainstem and cerebellum and diffuse cortical atrophy. Diffuse high-intensity signal changes may be seen in the corona radiata on T2-weighted MRI.
Thyrotoxicosis can acutely result in chorea. Both generalized chorea and hemichorea have been reported. In most reports the chorea resolves once the patient is euthyroid, but cases of persistent chorea have occurred. Animal experiments suggest that the mechanism may be related to increased dopamine receptor sensitivity during thyrotoxicosis.
Neuroferritinopathy is an autosomal dominant choreic syndrome first identified in a North West England family. The mean age at onset is 39 years, and 50% of patients have chorea as their first symptom. The chorea is typically symmetrical. Eye movements are normal and there is an associated late-onset dementia of the frontal/subcortical type. The disease arises from deficits in the ferritin light polypeptide (FTL) gene. T2-weighted MRI aids greatly in distinguishing this condition from other choreas; the hallmark of this disease is hypointensity of the striatum and globus pallidus. Serum ferritin levels may be low, but this finding is insufficiently reliable for it to be diagnostic.
Polycythemia vera is a disease of red blood cell hyperproliferation that has been associated with numerous neurological symptoms, including migraine, vertigo, and chorea. Chorea may be this disease’s initial symptom. Most cases of polycythemia-associated chorea have occurred acutely in elderly women and in the setting of hematologic deterioration. Chorea is not typically seen in patients with secondary polycythemia.
Chorea gravidarum is a choreic syndrome of pregnancy, usually with onset in the first or second trimester. The severity of the chorea tends to decrease as the pregnancy progresses. The syndrome appears to be associated with autoimmune disease. Investigators in one series of patients with the syndrome reported rheumatic heart disease in five of five patients, but other series have not been as definitive. Chorea gravidarum has been associated with systemic lupus erythematosus and with elevated antiphospholipid antibody titers. Approximately a third of patients see their symptoms resolve after delivery.
Painful leg and moving toes syndrome (PLMTS) is a condition characterized by involuntary movement of the toes in the presence of chronic pain. This movement typically takes the form of low-amplitude flexion-abduction movements that may persist during sleep. The movements have been associated with lesions in the spinal cord, nerve root, or peripheral nerves. Soft tissue injury has also been associated with PLMTS. The pathophysiology of these movements remains unclear. PLMTS should always be distinguished from pseudoathetosis by checking joint position sense. PLMTS does not always manifest as chorea and may instead appear as a persistent jerking movement.
A painless variant has also been reported and has been referred to as painless legs–moving toes syndrome.
Jumpy stump refers to the involuntary twitching of an amputation stump. It is usually accompanied by severe pain. As with PLMTS, this syndrome may resemble myoclonus more than chorea.
Chorea may be an unusual manifestation of Wilson disease (15%) or Friedreich ataxia . It is also an uncommon finding in Lesch-Nyhan syndrome (23%). Paroxysmal nonkinesigenic dyskinesia (PNKD) and paroxysmal kinesigenic dyskinesia (PKD) may manifest with chorea-like movements, as may SCA2, SCA3, and SCA17. These syndromes are dealt with more extensively in subsequent sections.
Myoclonus is a sudden, arrhythmic, involuntary movement that is “shock-like” in its rapidity. When multiple, these movements do not flow into one another, which distinguishes them from chorea. True myoclonus is due to brief synchronous firing of agonist and antagonist muscles that typically lasts 10 to 50 milliseconds and rarely more than 100 milliseconds. ,
Myoclonus can be classified by phenomenology, extent, or trigger. Positive myoclonus occurs with active muscle contraction, of which hypnic jerks, a sudden bodywide contraction that occurs as a person drifts between sleep and wakefulness, are a commonly experienced example. Negative myoclonus manifests as brief inhibition of a given muscle group. Asterixis is an example of negative myoclonus and consists of sudden and involuntary relaxation of a dorsiflexed hand or other body part. The EMG pattern of negative myoclonus is distinctive, with aperiodic electrophysiologic silences ranging from 0.05 to 0.5 second in the antagonist muscle groups. , When frequent, these signs can be mistaken for postural tremor.
Alternatively, myoclonus may be defined by the portion of the nervous system deemed responsible for the symptoms, such as cortical myoclonus, subcortical myoclonus, or spinal myoclonus. Finally, myoclonus can be classified as simply epileptic or nonepileptic. When myoclonus is triggered by movement, it is referred to as action-induced myoclonus. When myoclonus occurs in response to a touch or loud noise, the term stimulus sensitive applies. The phenomenon of hyperekplexia —an exaggerated startle response to a sudden, unexpected stimulus—is an example of stimulus-sensitive myoclonus.
Myoclonus is most often encountered as one of a collection of symptoms rather than as a pathology’s primary manifestation. Symptomatic myoclonus may be a feature of any process involving cortical, basal ganglionic, or cerebellar degeneration, such as Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease or PD. Hepatic, renal, endocrine, and other metabolic derangements may variably manifest as myoclonus. Primary myoclonic syndromes include the myoclonic epilepsies, essential hereditary myoclonus, palatal myoclonus, nocturnal myoclonus (also referred to as periodic leg movements of sleep), minipolymyoclonus, and physiologic myoclonus.
Focal myoclonus arises from focal activation of the peripheral nervous system or CNS. It takes its character from the region affected and from the underlying disease pathology.
Peripheral myoclonus arises when some pathologic process results in motor neuron irritation. It may develop after radiation damage or from nerve compression secondary to tumor. The myoclonus is limited to the territory supplied by the lesioned nerve or root and persists during sleep.
Palatal myoclonus is characterized by rhythmic contractions of the palate. Given its rhythmic nature, it is usually classified as palatal tremor and is discussed in the tremor section of this chapter.
Spinal segmental myoclonus is characterized by isolated contraction of muscles controlled by a particular spinal segment. It may follow spinal cord trauma, a mass lesion (tumor, vascular, or infectious), or inflammatory disease (such as multiple sclerosis). The symptoms may occur immediately after a spinal lesion or may follow the insult by decades. One series reported an average of 3 years between spinal damage and the onset of symptoms.
Epilepsia partialis continua (EPC) is defined as a localized muscular twitching of long duration without impairment of consciousness and arises from cortical epileptiform discharges that do not spread. EPC may develop as a result of intracranial neoplasms, encephalitides, mitochondrial disorders, and metabolic disorders or may be idiopathic in origin. The most common cause of EPC in childhood is Rasmussen encephalitis.
Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles
If you are a member. Log in here