Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
The clinical evaluation can usually distinguish disorders of muscle from those of the central nervous system (CNS) and peripheral nervous system (PNS) ( Table 6.1 ). It can then divide muscle disorders into those of the neuromuscular junction and those of the muscles themselves, myopathies ( Box 6.1 ). Surprisingly, considering their physiologic distance from the brain, several muscle disorders are associated with mental retardation, cognitive decline, personality changes, or use of psychotropic medications.
CNS | Nerve | Muscle | |
---|---|---|---|
Paresis | Pattern a | Distal | Proximal |
Muscle tone | Spastic | Flaccid | Sometimes tender or dystrophic |
DTRs | Hyperactive | Hypoactive | Normal or hypoactive |
Babinski signs | Yes | No | No |
Sensory loss | Pattern | Stocking-glove | None |
Myasthenia gravis
Lambert-Eaton syndrome
Botulism
Nerve gas poisoning
Black widow spider bite
Inherited dystrophies
Duchenne muscular dystrophy
Myotonic dystrophy
Polymyositis (Inflammatory, infectious, and toxic)
Polymyositis
Eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome
Trichinosis
AIDS myopathy
Metabolic
Steroid myopathy
Hypokalemic myopathy
Alcohol myopathy
Mitochondrial myopathies
Primary mitochondrial myopathies
Progressive ophthalmoplegia
MELAS and MERRF
Neuroleptic malignant syndrome
Normally, the presynaptic neuron at the neuromuscular junction releases discrete amounts—packets or quanta —of acetylcholine (ACh) into the neuromuscular junction. The neurotransmitter engages receptors on the muscle membrane to trigger a contraction ( Fig. 6.1 ). After the muscle contraction, acetylcholinesterase (AChE) (or simply “cholinesterase”) metabolizes ACh.
In myasthenia gravis (MG) , the classic neuromuscular junction disorder, antibodies against the ACh receptor block binding of ACh to the receptor, leading to development of weakness and respiratory difficulty. Other illnesses and some medications may also impair ACh transmission at the neuromuscular junction, although through different mechanisms, and cause the same problems. For example, botulinum toxin , as both a naturally occurring food poison and a medication, blocks the release of ACh packets from the presynaptic membrane and causes paresis (see later).
At the postsynaptic side of the neuromuscular junction, the muscle relaxant succinylcholine binds to the ACh receptors. With their ACh receptors inactivated, muscles weaken to the point of flaccid paralysis. Succinylcholine, which resists cholinesterases, has a paralyzing effect that lasts for hours. It facilitates major surgery and electroconvulsive therapy (ECT).
ACh, unlike dopamine and serotonin, serves as a transmitter both at the neuromuscular junction and in the CNS. Also, metabolism, instead of reuptake, almost entirely terminates its action. Antibodies associated with MG impair neuromuscular junction but not CNS ACh transmission: One reason is that neuromuscular ACh receptors are nicotinic , and cerebral ACh receptors are mostly muscarinic (see Chapter 21 ).
MG patients with almost complete paralysis but normal cognitive status illustrate the stark contrast between impaired neuromuscular junction ACh activity and preserved CNS ACh activity. Similarly, most anticholinesterase medications used to treat MG have no effect on cognitive status or other CNS function because they do not penetrate the blood-brain barrier. One of the few exceptions, physostigmine, penetrates into the CNS where it preserves ACh concentrations. Thus, researchers proposed physostigmine as a treatment for conditions with low CNS ACh levels, such as Alzheimer disease. However, in various experiments with Alzheimer disease, despite increasing cerebral ACh concentrations, physostigmine produced no clinical benefit (see Chapter 7 ).
In MG, ACh receptor antibodies block, impair, or destroy ACh receptors ( Fig. 6.2 ). These antibodies predominantly attack ACh receptors located in the extraocular, facial, neck and proximal limb muscles. When binding to antibody-inactivated receptors, ACh produces only weak, unsustained muscle contractions. Another characteristic of the ACh receptor antibodies is they attack only nicotinic ACh (not muscarinic) receptors. Moreover, they do not penetrate the blood brain barrier and do not interfere with CNS function. In contrast, they readily pass through the placenta and cause transient MG symptoms in neonates of mothers with MG.
In approximately 80% of MG cases, the serum contains ACh receptor antibodies. In one-half of the remainder, the serum has antibodies to muscle-specific kinase (MuSK) .
MG has a signature: weakness of the ocular motility (oculomotor), facial, and bulbar muscles that is asymmetric and fluctuating. Neurologists always suspect neuromuscular junction disease when they elicit a history of this “fatiguing” weakness, and they frequently find it on physical examination. The susceptibility of those muscles and the asymmetry remain unexplained. However, the weakness, at least in the initial months of the illness, varies in almost a diurnal pattern because exertion weakens muscles and thus symptoms appear predominantly in the late afternoon or early evening as well as after vigorous activities. Rest and sleep temporarily restore strength.
Almost 90% of patients, typically young women or older men, develop diplopia and ptosis as their first symptoms. When facial and neck muscle weakness emerges, a nasal tone suffuses patients’ speech, and they grimace when attempting to smile ( Fig. 6.3 ). These patients have significant trouble whistling and chewing. Neck, shoulder, swallowing, and respiratory muscles weaken as the disease progresses, that is, MG causes bulbar palsy (see Chapter 4 ). In severe cases, patients suffer respiratory distress, quadriplegia, and inability to speak (anarthria) . Paralysis can spread and worsen so much that patients reach a “locked-in” state (see Chapter 11 ).
Absence of certain findings is equally important. Again, compared to the physical incapacity, neither the disease nor the medications directly produce changes in mentation or level of consciousness. In addition, although extraocular muscles weaken, intraocular muscles remain strong. Thus, patients may have complete ptosis and no eyeball movement, but their pupils are normal in size and reactivity to light. Another oddity is that even though patients may develop quadriparesis, their bladder and bowel sphincters’ strength remain normal. Of course, as in muscle disorders, MG does not impair sensation.
Although exacerbations of MG often occur spontaneously, about 40% of pregnant women with MG undergo exacerbations, which occur with equal frequency during each trimester. On the other hand, about 30% of pregnant women with MG enjoy a remission. Intercurrent illnesses, such as pneumonia, or psychologic stress may also precipitate a flare-up.
Notably, the SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) pandemic, which quickly spread across the globe beginning in 2020, caused severe MG exacerbations. The underlying pathophysiology was likely a combination of baseline patient immunosuppression, predilection of the virus to cause pneumonia, and an overwhelming inflammatory response to the infection. Additionally, initial medications used for treatment of COVID-19, particularly azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine, worsen MG symptoms, even in the absence of infection.
There are no known risks of COVID-19 vaccination specific to patients with MG or other neuromuscular disorders. However, patients who receive immunosuppressive therapy may have to adjust the timing of their vaccinations because treatments may transiently impair the efficacy of vaccinations. Neurologists have otherwise encouraged their patients to obtain the vaccine without delay.
Another newly described cause of myasthenia is an occasionally occurring adverse reaction to immune checkpoint inhibitor treatment for certain cancers (see Chapter 19 ). This iatrogenic disorder causes the same clinical features as common MG; however, it is often accompanied by inflammatory myocarditis. In a minority of these cases, the serum shows antibodies to ACh receptors (see later).
For decades, neurologists confirmed a clinical diagnosis of myasthenia by performing a “Tensilon Test” (see Fig. 6.3 ), which entailed an intravenous injection of the cholinesterase inhibitor edrophonium (Tensilon). However, because edrophonium often produces a sudden increase in systemic cholinergic activity, it caused bradycardia and other adverse effects. Neurologists sometimes perform the less risky ice pack test that presumably slows the kinetics of AChE and thereby improves neuromuscular transmission (see Fig. 6.3 , bottom ). Although both tests may produce dramatic improvements in facial or ocular mobility, the changes are brief, and the tests produce a substantial number of false-positive and false-negative results.
For a firm diagnosis, neurologists now rely on serum tests to detect antibodies to ACh receptors or, in certain circumstances, antibodies to MuSK. They may also perform repetitive nerve stimulation testing at low frequency. In this test, affected muscles characteristically show a decremental response by contracting less and less to the stimulation.
Lesions of the oculomotor nerve (cranial nerve III), which may be a sign of a midbrain infarction (see Fig. 4.9 ) or nerve compression by a posterior communicating artery aneurysm, also cause extraocular muscle paresis. In addition to their usually having an abrupt and painful onset, these lesions are identifiable by a subtle finding: the pupil will be widely dilated and unreactive to light due to intraocular (pupillary) muscle paresis (see Fig. 4.6 ). In addition, many other neurologic illnesses cause facial and bulbar palsy: amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), botulism, Guillain-Barré syndrome, Lambert-Eaton syndrome, and Lyme disease, among others. Rarely, a patient will report the sudden onset of dysarthria, dysphagia, and diplopia and ultimately receive the diagnosis of conversion disorder.
Standard treatments for MG attempt to either increase ACh concentration at the neuromuscular junction or restore the integrity of ACh receptors. To increase ACh concentration by slowing its metabolism, neurologists typically prescribe long-acting cholinesterase inhibitors (or simply, anticholinesterases ) , such as pyridostigmine (Mestinon). If patients cannot swallow, neurologists usually order intravenous or intramuscular neostigmine (Prostigmin). By increasing ACh activity, these medicines increase muscle strength.
In the other therapeutic strategy, restoring the integrity of ACh receptors, neurologists administer steroids, other immunosuppressive medications, plasmapheresis (plasma exchange), or intravenous infusions of immunoglobulins (IVIG). In refractory cases of MG, neurologists also use the synthetic monoclonal antibody rituximab (Rituxan), which binds to the CD20 antigen on B-cells. Rituximab depletes these cells and thereby suppresses the hyperimmune response that had caused the patient’s symptoms. Neurologists also infuse IVIG in Guillain-Barré syndrome and rituximab in refractory forms of chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (CIDP) [see Chapter 5 ]. For patients who have symptoms resistant to or intolerant of older therapies, the monoclonal antibody complement inhibitor eculizumab has been approved more recently for the treatment of AChR antibody-positive MG. This expensive infusion must be given every 2 weeks but has been shown to reduce disease severity. Additionally, patients receiving this newer medication must be vaccinated against meningococcal diseases as the immune response to this infection requires the complement cascade.
About 5% of MG patients have underlying hyperthyroidism, and 10% have a mediastinal thymoma. If these conditions are present and respond to treatment, MG will usually improve.
As in myasthenia, impaired ACh neuromuscular transmission causes weakness in Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome (LEMS) and botulism. The major physiologic distinction is that myasthenia results from a disorder of postsynaptic receptors, but LEMS and botulism result from impaired release of presynaptic ACh packets.
LEMS and botulism also differ in their etiology and, to a certain extent, their clinical manifestations. A toxin causes botulism, but an autoimmune disorder, probably from serum voltage-gated calcium channel (VGCC) antibodies, causes LEMS (see Chapter 19 ). This autoimmune disorder, in turn, is frequently an expression of small cell carcinoma of the lung and occasionally a component of a rheumatologic illness. When associated with any cancer, neurologists consider LEMS a paraneoplastic syndrome (see Chapter 19 ).
Although LEMS and MG both cause weakness, LEMS usually first causes weakness of the limbs, while MG most commonly first causes extraocular, head, and neck weakness. Moreover, repetitive exertion temporarily corrects weakness in LEMS, presumably by provoking presynaptic ACh release, but any exertion exacerbates myasthenia-induced weakness. In addition, LEMS, unlike MG, causes autonomic nervous system dysfunction. Because of this autonomic dysfunction, LEMS patients may also have a sluggish or absent pupillary light reflex, which would unequivocally set them apart from MG patients.
Unlike LEMS, botulism is an infectious illness that usually results from eating contaminated food. Most often, improperly preserved food has allowed the growth of Clostridium botulinum spores that elaborate a toxin with a predilection for the presynaptic neuromuscular membrane. (Experts fear terrorists might inject these spores into commercial food manufacturing processes, such as milk pasteurizing, to create mass poisonings).
Botulism victims develop oculomotor, bulbar, and respiratory paralyses that resemble Guillain-Barré syndrome as well as MG. However, in contrast to the course of these illnesses, botulism symptoms arise explosively and include dilated unreactive pupils.
A unique feature of botulism, which may prompt a life-saving diagnosis, is that several family members often simultaneously develop constipation, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and fever, and then the distinctive weakness with fixed pupils 18 to 36 hours after sharing a meal. Botulism, as well as tetanus (see later), may also complicate drug abuse that involves shared, contaminated needles. It develops in infants fed unpasteurized (raw) honey or corn syrup that harbor the infective spores. Treatment often requires intubation and ventilatory support.
Ironically, neurologists now routinely turn botulinum-induced paresis to an advantage. They inject pharmaceutically prepared botulinum toxin to alleviate focal dystonias and dyskinesias, such as blepharospasm, spasmodic torticollis, and writer’s cramp (see Chapter 18 ). Even more ironically, dermatologists routinely inject pharmaceutically prepared botulinum toxin into the paper-thin muscles underlying furrows to smooth patients’ skin.
A different Clostridium species elaborates the neurotoxin that causes tetanus. In this illness, the toxin from Clostridium tetani predominantly blocks presynaptic release, not of ACh, but of the inhibitory CNS neurotransmitters, gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), and glycine (see Chapter 21 ). The disease deprives patients of the normal inhibitory influence on their brain and spinal cord motor neurons. Uninhibited muscle contractions cause trismus (“lockjaw”), facial grimacing, an odd but characteristic smile (“risus sardonicus”), and muscle spasms in the limbs. The muscle contractions may be so violent that bursts of spasms mimic seizures that neurologists term “tetanic convulsions.”
Drug addicts who share infected needles and workers in farming and scrap metal recovery contract tetanus. When abortion was illegal, tetanus as well as other fatal infections, frequently complicated the procedure.
Although acutely developing facial, jaw, trunk, and limb spasms are indicative of tetanus, dopamine-blocking medications commonly produce similarly appearing dystonic reactions. Thus, neurologists must not blindly attribute all facial and jaw spasms to medication-induced dystonic reactions. The differential diagnosis of these muscle spasms includes strychnine poisoning, rabies, heatstroke, and head and neck infections, as well as tetanus and dystonic reactions.
Strychnine poisoning allows for an interesting comparison to tetanus. Lack of inhibitory neurotransmitter activity in both conditions underlies muscle spasms. One minor difference is strychnine does not lead to trismus. The major difference is tetanus results from impaired presynaptic release of the inhibitory neurotransmitters GABA and glycine. Still, strychnine is an antagonist of these same inhibitory neurotransmitters at their postsynaptic receptors.
Most common insecticides are organophosphates that bind and inactivate AChE. With inactivation of its metabolic enzyme, ACh accumulates and irreversibly depolarizes postsynaptic neuromuscular junctions. After insecticides cause initial muscle contractions and fasciculations, they lead to paralysis of respiratory and other muscles. For example, malathion (Ovide), the common shampoo for head lice, irreversibly inhibits AChE. It is safe as a shampoo because little penetrates through the skin.
On the other hand, people committing suicide, especially in India, often deliberately drink organophosphate pesticides. Similarly, the nerve gases that threatened soldiers from World War I through the Persian Gulf War bind and inactivate AChE. The common ones—GA, GB, GD, and VX—affect both the CNS and PNS. Some are gaseous, but others, such as sarin (GB), the poison used in the Tokyo subway terrorist attack, are liquid. Several investigators postulated that pyridostigmine caused neurologic symptoms of the “Gulf War syndrome,” though this was not supported by evidence (see later).
Accumulation of ACh from poison gas or excessive pyridostigmine treatment in MG patients causes a cholinergic crisis . Its initial features—tearing, pulmonary secretions, and miosis—reflect excessive cholinergic (parasympathetic) activity. If the poisons penetrate the CNS, further excess ACh causes convulsions, rapidly developing unconsciousness, and respiratory depression.
Medical personnel will ideally receive a warning that enables them to provide pretreatment. They might administer pyridostigmine, a reversible AChE inhibitor, as a prophylactic agent because it occupies the vulnerable site on AChE and thereby protects it from irreversible inhibition by the toxin. After nerve gas exposure or liquid ingestion, first aid consists of washing exposed skin with dilute bleach (hypochlorite). Also, after exposure, field forces administer pralidoxime because it reactivates AChE and detoxifies organophosphates, and atropine because it is a competitive inhibitor of ACh and blocks the excessive cholinergic activity. In view of a high incidence of seizures, depending on the exposure, field forces also often administer a benzodiazepine. Other antiepileptic drugs are ineffective in this situation.
Survivors of nerve gas attacks often report development of headaches, personality changes, and cognitive impairment, especially affecting memory. Their symptoms often mimic those of posttraumatic stress disorder. Experience has also shown individuals in the vicinity of a nerve gas attack, but who were not exposed and remain entirely well, i.e., the “worried-well,” overwhelm emergency rooms.
Agent Orange , the herbicide sprayed extensively in Southeast Asia during the Vietnam War, allegedly produced cognitive impairment, psychiatric disturbances, and brain tumors. Although scientific reviews found no evidence that it actually caused any of those problems, advocacy groups have prodded Congress into accepting a causal relationship.
Veterans with the recent counterpart, Persian Gulf War syndrome , also described varied symptoms, including fatigue, weakness, and myalgia (painful muscle aches). Again, exhaustive studies have found no consistent, significant clinical sign or laboratory evidence of any neurologic sequelae. One theory has been that in anticipation of a nerve gas attack, soldiers were ordered to take a “neurotoxic” antidote (pyridostigmine); however, numerous MG patients have taken it for decades with no such adverse effects.
The notion that silicone toxicity from breast implants causes a neuromuscular disorder and other neurologic illness, which is also unfounded, is discussed in the differential diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (see Chapter 15 ).
Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles
If you are a member. Log in here