Injury Control


In all high-income countries of the world, and increasingly in many low- and middle-income countries, injuries are the most common cause of death during childhood and adolescence beyond the 1st few mo of life ( Table 13.1 and Fig. 13.1 ). Injuries represent one of the most important causes of preventable pediatric morbidity and mortality in the United States. Identification of risk factors for injuries has led to the development of successful programs for prevention and control. Strategies for injury prevention and control should be pursued by the pediatrician in the office, emergency department (ED), hospital, and community setting and should be done in a multidisciplinary, multifaceted way.

Table 13.1
Injury Deaths in the United States, 2015 * [N (Rate per 100,000)]
CAUSE OF DEATH <1 yr 1-4 yr 5-9 yr 10-14 yr 15-19 yr 0-19 yr
ALL CAUSES 23,161 (583.4) 4045 (25.3) 2490 (12.2) 3013 (14.6) 10,812 (51.2) 43,521 (53.0)
ALL INJURIES 1616 (40.70) 1660 (10.40) 960 (4.70) 1468 (7.12) 8148 (39.03) 13,952 (16.99)
All unintentional 1219 (30.70) 1261 (7.90) 787 (3.85) 847 (4.11) 4152 (19.65) 8266 (10.07)
Motor vehicle occupant 26 (0.65) 80 (0.50) 111 (0.54) 144 (0.70) 748 (3.54) 1109 (1.35)
Pedestrian 12 (0.30) 175 (1.10) 98 (0.48) 117 (0.57) 329 (1.56) 731 (0.89)
Drowning 38 (0.96) 425 (2.66) 147 (0.72) 103 (0.50) 253 (1.20) 966 (1.18)
Fire and burn 13 (0.33) 107 (0.67) 78 (0.38) 52 (0.25) 35 (0.17) 285 (0.35)
Poisoning 9 (0.23) 34 (0.21) 13 (0.06) 28 (0.14) 771 (3.65) 855 (1.04)
Bicycle 0 (0.00) 6 (0.04) 15 (0.07) 38 (0.18) 45 (0.21) 104 (0.13)
Firearm 1 (0.03) 34 (0.21) 16 (0.08) 23 (0.11) 53 (0.25) 127 (0.15)
Fall 7 (0.16) 19 (0.12) 5 (0.02) 14 (0.07) 66 (0.31) 111 (0.14)
Suffocation 1023 (25.77) 118 (0.74) 35 (0.17) 39 (0.19) 43 (0.20) 1258 (1.53)
All intentional 276 (6.95) 339 (2.12) 146 (0.71) 585 (2.84) 3959 (18.74) 5305 (6.46)
Suicide 0 (0.00) 0 (0.00) 7 (0.03) 436 (2.11) 2117 (10.02) 2560 (3.12)
Firearm suicide 0 (0.00) 0 (0.00) 0 (0.00) 160 (0.78) 942 (4.46) 1102 (1.34)
Homicide 276 (6.95) 339 (2.12) 139 (0.68) 147 (0.71) 1816 (8.59) 2717 (3.13)
Firearm homicide 11 (0.28) 64 (0.40) 68 (0.33) 95 (0.46) 1611 (7.62) 1849 (2.25)
Undetermined intent 121 (3.05) 60 (0.38) 27 (0.13) 36 (0.17) 137 (0.65) 381 (0.46)
All-cause data from CDC, National Center for Health Statistics: Compressed Mortality File 1999–2015, Series 20, No 2U, 2016, as compiled from data provided by the 57 vital statistics jurisdictions through the Vital Statistics Cooperative Program, CDC WONDER online database, October 2018.

* Injury data from US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC): Web-based Injury Statistics Query and Reporting System (WISQARS) (website). National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, CDC (producer). https://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/ .

Fig. 13.1
Global injury deaths to children, adolescents, and young adults, 0-29 yr of age, 2012.

(From WHO: Injuries and Violence: The Facts 2012. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2014.)

Injuries have identifiable risk and protective factors that can be used to define prevention strategies. The term accidents implies a chance event occurring without pattern or predictability. In fact, most injuries occur under fairly predictable circumstances to high-risk children and families. Most injuries are preventable.

Reduction of morbidity and mortality from injuries can be accomplished not only through primary prevention (averting the event or injury), but also through secondary and tertiary prevention. The latter 2 approaches include appropriate emergency medical services (EMS) for injured children; regionalized trauma care for the child with multiple injuries, severe burns, or traumatic brain injury; and specialized pediatric rehabilitation services that attempt to return children to their previous level of functioning.

Injury control also encompasses intentional injuries (assaults and self-inflicted injuries). These injuries are important in adolescents and young adults, and in some populations, these rank 1st or 2nd as causes of death in these age-groups. Many of the same principles of injury control can be applied to these problems; for example, limiting access to firearms may reduce both unintentional shootings, homicides, and suicides.

Scope of the Problem

Mortality

In the United States, injuries cause 42% of deaths among 1-4 yr old children and 3.5 times more deaths than the next leading cause, congenital anomalies. For the rest of childhood and adolescence up to age 19 yr, 64% of deaths are a result of injuries, more than all other causes combined. In 2016, injuries caused 13,952 deaths (16.78 deaths per 100,000 population) among individuals ≤19 yr old in the United States, resulting in more years of potential life lost than any other cause. Unintentional injuries remained the leading cause of death among those <24 yr old in 2016 (see Table 13.1 and Fig. 13.1 ).

Motor vehicle injuries lead the list of injury deaths among school-age children and adolescents and are the 2nd leading cause of injury death for those age 1-4 yr. In children and adults, motor vehicle occupant injuries account for the majority of these deaths. During adolescence, occupant injuries are the leading cause of injury death, accounting for >50% of unintentional trauma mortality in this age-group.

Drowning ranks 2nd overall as a cause of unintentional injury deaths among those age 1-19 yr, with peaks in the preschool and later teenage years (see Chapter 91 ). In some areas of the United States, drowning is the leading cause of death from trauma for preschool-age children. The causes of drowning deaths vary with age and geographic area. In young children, bathtub and swimming pool drowning predominates, whereas in older children and adolescents, drowning occurs predominantly in natural bodies of water while the victim is swimming or boating.

Fire- and burn-related deaths account for 3% of all unintentional trauma deaths, with the highest rates among those <5 yr of age (see Chapter 92 ). Most deaths are a result of house fires and are caused by smoke inhalation or asphyxiation rather than severe burns. Children and elderly persons are at greatest risk for these deaths because of difficulty in escaping from burning buildings.

Suffocation accounts for approximately 87% of all unintentional deaths in children <1 yr old. Some cases result from choking on food items, such as hot dogs, candy, grapes, and nuts. Nonfood items that can cause choking include undersize infant pacifiers, small balls, and latex balloons. An increasing number of infant suffocation deaths represent sleep-related mortality in the presence of unsafe bedding, crib bumpers, or cosleeping with an impaired adult. In previous years these might have been classified as sudden infant death syndrome (see Chapter 402 ).

Homicide is the 3rd leading cause of injury death in children 1-4 yr old and the 3rd leading cause of injury death in adolescents (15-19 yr old) ( Fig. 13.2 ). Homicide in the pediatric age-group falls into 2 patterns: infant (child) and adolescent. Child homicide involves children <5 yr old and represents child abuse (see Chapter 16 ). The perpetrator is usually a caretaker; death is generally the result of blunt trauma to the head and/or abdomen. The adolescent pattern of homicide involves peers and acquaintances and is caused by firearms in 88% of cases. The majority of these deaths involve handguns. Children between these 2 age-groups experience homicides of both types.

Fig. 13.2, Chart showing 3rd leading cause of death (homicide) among persons age 10-24 yr compared with 4th through 10th leading causes of death in the same age-group in the United States in 2013. *Does not include the 2 leading causes of death among persons age 10-24 yr in 2013: unintentional injuries (12,394 deaths) and suicide (5,264); † congenital anomalies; § cerebrovascular diseases.

Suicide is rare in children <10 yr old; only 1% of all suicides occur in children <15 yr. The suicide rate increases greatly after age 10 yr, with the result that suicide is now the 2nd leading cause of death for 15-19 yr olds. Native American teenagers are at the highest risk, followed by white males; black females have the lowest rate of suicide in this age-group. Approximately 40% of teenage suicides involve firearms (see Chapter 40 ).

There has been a sharp and substantial increase in unintentional poisoning deaths among teens and young adults. In 2016, unintentional poisonings were the 2nd leading cause of injury deaths among 15-24 yr olds. Many of these were from prescription analgesic and opioid medications such as fentanyl.

Nonfatal Injuries

Most childhood injuries do not result in death. Approximately 12% of children and adolescents receive medical care for an injury each year in hospital EDs, and at least as many are treated in physicians’ offices. Of these, 2% require inpatient care, and 55% have at least short-term temporary disability as a result of their injuries.

The distribution of nonfatal injuries is very different from that of fatal trauma ( Fig. 13.3 ). Falls are the leading cause of both ED visits and hospitalizations. Bicycle-related trauma is the most common type of sports and recreational injury, accounting for approximately 300,000 ED visits annually. Nonfatal injuries , such as anoxic encephalopathy from near-drowning, scarring and disfigurement from burns, and persistent neurologic deficits from head injury, may be associated with severe morbidity, leading to substantial changes in the quality of life for victims and their families. In 2010, nonfatal injuries to U.S. children <19 yr old resulted in >$32 billion in direct medical and lifetime work loss costs.

Fig. 13.3, Emergency department visits for injuries, United States 2016.

Global Child Injuries

Child injuries are a global public health issue, and prevention efforts are necessary in low-, middle-, and high-income countries. Between 1990 and 2010 there was a 53% decrease in mortality of people of all ages from communicable, maternal, neonatal, and nutritional disorders, while injury mortality decreased by only 16% ( Fig. 13.4 ).

Fig. 13.4, Rates of disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs) loss per 100,000 per year by major grouping of cause.

Worldwide, almost 1 million children and adolescents die from injuries and violence each year, and >90% of these deaths are in low- and middle-income countries. As child mortality undergoes an epidemiologic transition because of better control of infectious diseases and malnutrition, injuries have and will increasingly become the leading cause of death for children in the developing world, as it now is in all industrialized countries. Drowning is the 5th most common cause of death for 5-9 yr old children globally, and in some countries, such as Bangladesh, it is the leading cause of death among children beyond the 1st yr of life, with a rate 22 times greater than that in the Americas. An estimated 1 billion people do not currently have immediate access to roads; as industrialization and motorization spreads, the incidence of motor vehicle crashes, injuries, and fatalities will climb. The rate of child injury death in low- and middle-income countries is 3-fold higher than that in high-income countries and reflects both a higher incidence of many types of injuries and a much higher case fatality rate in those injured because of a lack of access to emergency and surgical care. As in high-income countries, prevention of child injuries and consequent morbidity and mortality is feasible with multifaceted approaches, many of which are low cost and of proven effectiveness.

Principles of Injury Control

Injury prevention once centered on attempts to pinpoint the innate characteristics of a child that result in greater frequency of injury. Most discount the theory of the “accident-prone child.” Although longitudinal studies have demonstrated an association between attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and increased rates of injury, the sensitivity and specificity of these traits as a test to identify individuals at high risk for injury are extremely low. The concept of accident proneness is counterproductive in that it shifts attention away from potentially more modifiable factors, such as product design or the environment. It is more appropriate to examine the physical and social environment of children with frequent rates of injury than to try to identify particular personality traits or temperaments, which are difficult to modify. Children at high risk for injury are likely to be relatively poorly supervised, to have disorganized or stressed families, and to live in hazardous environments.

Efforts to control injuries include education or persuasion, changes in product design, and modification of the social and physical environment. Efforts to persuade individuals, particularly parents, to change their behaviors have constituted the greater part of injury control efforts. Speaking with parents specifically about using child car-seat restraints and bicycle helmets, installing smoke detectors, and checking the tap water temperature is likely to be more successful than offering well-meaning but too-general advice about supervising the child closely, being careful, and childproofing the home. This information should be geared to the developmental stage of the child and presented in moderate doses in the form of anticipatory guidance at well-child visits. Table 13.2 lists important topics to discuss at each developmental stage. It is important to acknowledge that there are many barriers to prevention adherence beyond simple knowledge acquisition; pediatricians should be familiar with low-cost sources for safety equipment such as bicycle helmets, smoke detectors, trigger locks, and car seats in their community.

Table 13.2
Injury Prevention Topics for Anticipatory Guidance by the Pediatrician

Newborn

  • Car seats

  • Tap water temperature

  • Smoke detectors

  • Sleep safe environments

Infant

  • Car seats

  • Tap water temperature

  • Bath safety

  • Choking prevention

Toddler and Preschooler

  • Car seats and booster seats

  • Water safety

  • Poison prevention

  • Fall prevention

Primary School Child

  • Pedestrian skills training

  • Water skills training

  • Booster seats and seat belts

  • Bicycle helmets

  • Safe storage of firearms in the home

Middle School Child

  • Seatbelts

  • Safe storage of firearms in the home

  • Water skills training

  • Sports safety and concussion prevention

High School and Older Adolescent

  • Seatbelts

  • Alcohol and drug use, especially while driving and swimming

  • Mobile phone use while driving

  • Safe storage of firearms

  • Sports safety and concussion prevention

  • Occupational injuries

The most successful injury prevention strategies generally are those involving changes in product design . These passive interventions protect all individuals in the population, regardless of cooperation or level of skill, and are likely to be more successful than active measures that require repeated behavior change by the parent or child. The most important and effective product changes have been in motor vehicles, in which protection of the passenger compartment and use of airbags have had large effects on injury risk. Turning down the water heater temperature, installing smoke detectors, and using child-resistant caps on medicines and household products are other examples of effective product modifications. Many interventions require both active and passive measures. Smoke detectors provide passive protection when fully functional, but behavior change is required to ensure periodic battery changes and proper testing.

Modification of the environment often requires greater changes than individual product modification but may be very effective in reducing injuries. Safe roadway design, decreased traffic volume and speed limits in neighborhoods, and elimination or safe storage of guns in households are examples of such interventions. Included in this concept are changes in the social environment through legislation, such as laws mandating child seat restraint and seatbelt use, bicycle helmet use, and graduated driver's licensing laws.

Prevention campaigns combining 2 or more of these approaches have been particularly effective in reducing injuries. The classic example is the combination of legislation/regulation and education to increase child seat restraint and seatbelt use; other examples are programs to promote bike helmet use among school-aged children and improvements in occupant protection in motor vehicles.

You're Reading a Preview

Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles

Become membership

If you are a member. Log in here