Approach to Women’s Health


An approach to the care of women must go beyond an understanding of differences in the incidence of disease between men and women. Providers need to consider the impact of sex differences (differences based on genetic and hormonal differences) and gender differences (differences attributable to the roles men and women are ascribed in society). Therapeutic decisions should take into account both genetic and environmental differences in the presentation of disease and the effectiveness of therapeutic options, the patient’s reproductive life stage, comorbid conditions, and the social and cultural contexts of care. The increased number of women participating in clinical research improved knowledge about women’s health, but gaps remain regarding the gender-specific impact of new therapies and interventions owing to a lack of data on the heterogeneity of impact by sex and gender.

Lifespan Groups

Many important women’s health issues are linked to the social, psychological, and biologic context at certain ages and stages of life. When considering both preventive care and common causes of mortality and morbidity, these lifespan stages provide a context for organizing care ( Table 219-1 ).

TABLE 219-1
IMPORTANT HEALTH ISSUES FOR WOMEN THROUGH THE LIFESPAN
ISSUE AGES
15-44 yr . 45-65 yr . 65+ yr .
Behavioral issues Risk behaviors
Sexual behavior
Smoking
Alcohol and drug use
Exercise
Diet
Risk behaviors
Smoking
Alcohol and drug use
Exercise
Diet
Risk behaviors
Smoking
Exercise
Social roles and needs Entering work force
Relationship transitions
Parenting
Caregiving to several generations
Caregiving to several generations
Transitions in family and work environments
Losses and social isolation
Poverty due to lower lifetime earnings
Reproductive issues Reproductive health issues Menopause transition
Injury Intentional and unintentional interpersonal violence
Motor vehicle injuries
Falls
Common causes of mortality and morbidity Depression
Anxiety
HIV/AIDS
Cancer
Obesity
Diabetes
Depression
Anxiety
Cardiovascular disease
Cancer
Cognitive decline
Osteoporosis
Osteoarthritis
Incontinence
Depression
Anxiety
AIDS = acquired immunodeficiency syndrome; HIV = human immunodeficiency virus.

For most women, young adulthood (15 to 44 years) is marked by social transitions in family structure, such as forming one’s own family, parenting, and entering the work force. Competing demands of career development and of child and eldercare needs affect both a woman’s health and her own health care. During this age range, mortality rates are low, so health visits can focus on behavioral decisions that will influence the risk for future disease, such as sexual behavior, smoking ( Chapter 363 ), alcohol ( Chapter 364 ) and drug use ( Chapter 365 ), diet ( Chapter 13 ), and exercise ( Chapter 14 ). Major sources of morbidity include intentional and unintentional injury, including interpersonal violence ( Chapter 223 ) and motor vehicle injuries. Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV; Chapter 360 ) is a leading cause of morbidity and mortality in this age group. Depression and anxiety ( Chapter 362 ) are common in this and all life stages. Reproductive issues ( Chapter 218 ) are considered in most therapeutic decisions.

The middle years (ages 45 to 65 years) continue to be influenced by behavioral decisions, especially diet, exercise, and alcohol and substance use. The social context includes role changes as children reach adulthood; caregiving responsibilities are now for dependent children and possibly grandchildren, as well as aging parents. The menopausal transition ( Chapter 222 ) may be accompanied by new symptomatic concerns. Common causes of morbidity, including diabetes ( Chapter 210 ) and obesity ( Chapter 201 ), now reflect earlier behavioral decisions. Cancer is the leading cause of mortality.

Health issues in older women (65+ years) may occur in the context of loss of function and independence. Because women commonly survive their male partners, they are more likely at this stage of life to be unpartnered. Compared with older men, older women have a greater number of social needs, including social isolation, depression, and poverty from accumulated lower lifetime earnings. Cardiovascular disease is the major cause of mortality, followed by cancer, cerebrovascular disease, chronic obstructive lung disease, and pneumonia. Loss of independence is related to cognitive decline ( Chapter 371 ), osteoarthritis ( Chapter 241 ), osteoporotic fractures ( Chapter 225 ), and incontinence ( Chapter 115 ).

Health Disparities Among Women

The health status of women is heavily influenced by racial and ethnic differences in outcomes for most common causes of mortality and morbidity. Black Americans, women from many Asian and Pacific Island nations, Native Americans, and women of Latino background share poorer outcomes for a wide variety of conditions ( Chapter 4 ). This broad finding of poorer outcomes across many diverse ethnic and racial groups emphasizes the social determinants of health (e.g., income, education, violence, housing, and food insecurity, among others; see Chapter 4 ). Common recommendations for health promotion, including a diet low in animal fats and processed sugars but high in whole grains, fruits, nuts, and vegetables, along with regular exercise, such as walking, may be difficult to follow in high-crime neighborhoods or in locales where a variety of affordable, nutritious food options are not available. Barriers to health care access and poor adherence to medical therapy are more common in low-income women, who may have difficulty scheduling appointments that do not interfere with their work schedules or unpaid time off from clerical or service jobs. Low health literacy and cultural barriers can add to challenges in accessing health care. The need to care for dependent children or elders may interfere with women’s ability to address their own health care needs ( Chapter 4 ).

Common Causes of Mortality in Women

Cardiovascular Disease

Cardiovascular disease ( Chapter 40 ) is the overall leading cause of death in women. However, because cardiovascular-related death occurs most often in women older than age 65 years, its impact is often under-recognized or underestimated. Race and ethnicity play a large role in the risk for cardiovascular disease; Black women have much higher incidence and mortality rates than any other racial or ethnic group, and Latinas and Asian women also have higher rates than White populations.

The incidence rate of cardiovascular disease in women lags 10 years behind that of men from ages 40 through 70 years; that is, a 65-year-old woman has a similar risk to a 55-year-old man. There is no abrupt increase in the risk of cardiovascular disease at menopause in women, thereby suggesting that menopausal changes in estrogen or progesterone do not account for this sex difference. Randomized clinical trials have confirmed that combined estrogen/progestin hormone therapy in women does not prevent cardiovascular disease and is not indicated for cardiovascular disease prevention, but conjugated estrogen alone may reduce the risk of heart disease over the following 18 years when begun in women ages 50 to 59 years. Estrogen monotherapy or combined estrogen/progestin therapy has complex systemic effects, and the net rates of adverse outcomes when used for chronic disease prevention may vary according to an individual woman’s risk factor profile. For example, data suggest an overall benefit when estrogen therapy is started between the ages of 50 to 59 years but not if started later. Therefore, an individualized risk stratification approach is advocated in menopausal women who are otherwise potential candidates for hormone therapy because of other indications (see Chapter 222 ). Supplementation of calcium and vitamin D, which can improve bone health in women ( Chapter 225 ), is not indicated to prevent cardiovascular disease. Other risk factors for cardiovascular disease in women are the same as those in men: elevated lipid levels ( Chapter 190 ), lack of physical activity, obesity ( Chapter 201 ), smoking ( Chapter 363 ), hypertension ( Chapter 64 ), and diabetes ( Chapter 210 ). Women with diabetes have the same risk for cardiovascular disease as men of the same age with diabetes.

However, there are notable disparities in the burden of coronary heart disease among some groups of women, especially women who are disadvantaged because of race, ethnicity, income level, and educational attainment. Cigarette smoking continues to be an important behavioral risk factor for cardiovascular disease, especially in younger women, Native American women, and women with low incomes and low educational attainment. The incidence of many known risk factors, including obesity, hypertension, and hypercholesterolemia, is greater in Black women than in White women. Furthermore, data suggest that women are less likely to receive risk factor reduction therapy, a reflection of an inertia caused by clinicians’ misperceptions of their risk for heart disease.

The presentation of coronary artery disease in women differs from that in men. Although chest pain is the most common presentation in women, atypical and noncardiac pain is a more frequent presentation in women than in men, and fewer women have typical chest tightness or pressure as their presenting complaint. For this and other reasons, women often face delays in seeking and receiving emergency care for an acute coronary syndrome ( Chapter 57 ) or acute myocardial infarction ( Chapter 58 ), thereby increasing their risk for death and recurrent myocardial infarction.

Medical management is similar for men and women with acute coronary syndromes ( Chapter 57 ) and acute myocardial infarction ( Chapter 58 ). Women with ST-segment-elevation myocardial infarction or any high-risk women with non–ST-segment-elevation myocardial infarction obtain the same benefits from either percutaneous cardiac interventions of coronary bypass graft surgery ( Chapter 59 ) as do men, after controlling for other comorbid conditions, but women commonly have lower rates of revascularization. Recent randomized clinical trials indicate similar benefits of new therapies for heart failure for women and men, including sodium-glucose cotransporter-2 inhibitors, defibrillator use, and transitions of care support.

U.S. guidelines for the management of lipid disorders ( Chapter 190 ) are based on 10-year risk of cardiovascular disease as well as absolute lipid levels. Although these guidelines are not gender specific, they attempt to avoid overtreatment of younger women at very low risk while avoiding undertreatment of women with the lower low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol level but much higher overall risks of cardiovascular disease. High-intensity statin therapy is recommended as secondary prevention for women who have clinical atherosclerotic disease, as well as for primary prevention for women who have a 20% or greater risk of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, an LDL cholesterol level higher than 190 mg/dL, or diabetes and a 7.5% or greater 10-year risk of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease ( Chapter 190 ). A moderate-intensity statin is recommended for lower risk women with diabetes or with a 5 to 20% 10-year risk of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. Women lag behind men in use of medical therapy for lipid disorders, perhaps in part because of higher reported rates of adverse effects, especially from statins; however, most patients who report such symptoms can successfully use statins after a blinded trial (see Chapter 190 ).

Type 2 Diabetes

The rates of type 2 diabetes ( Chapter 210 ) continue to rise, with a greater risk in women who are overweight, obese, or physically inactive. Rates are higher in many racial and ethnic groups including Black, Asian, Native American, and Latina women than among White women. Lifestyle changes (primarily diet and exercise) can reduce the incidence of type 2 diabetes. No randomized clinical trials have shown that screening for diabetes is beneficial, but current U.S. guidelines recommend screening overweight or obese adults with a high A 1C level as part of their cardiovascular risk assessment beginning at age 35 and continuing to age 70 years. For women who develop gestational diabetes ( Chapter 221 ), the risk of developing type 2 diabetes later in life increases five-fold, so screening with hemoglobin A 1C levels at 6 to 12 weeks postpartum and every 3 years thereafter is recommended.

The incidence of diabetes is rising in women at younger ages, with significant perinatal and maternal health implications. Ongoing discussion of fertility control and family planning is critical in diabetic women with childbearing potential. Tight glycemic control before conception and through the first trimester is critical to reduce the risk for birth anomalies, and it is important later in pregnancy to reduce the risk for adverse fetal events, including macrosomia (large for gestational age) and preterm birth ( Chapter 221 ). Ideally, women planning a pregnancy should switch from oral agents to insulin, with home glucose monitoring for tight control ( Table 219-2 ). Risks of maternal complications from diabetes including vascular disease, retinopathy, hypertension, preeclampsia, renal disease, and neuropathy are general related to glycemic control before and during pregnancy and usually not specifically due to pregnancy itself.

TABLE 219-2
PREFERRED MEDICATIONS FOR WOMEN OF REPRODUCTIVE POTENTIAL
COMMON CONDITIONS IN WOMEN OF REPRODUCTIVE POTENTIAL ISSUES TO BE AWARE OF PREFERRED MEDICATIONS OR GROUPS OF MEDICATIONS
Depression Must consider effects of untreated depression on mother and infant Avoid newer medications when older drugs with more information are available
SSRIs are generally considered safe; fluoxetine has most safety data
Anxiety Commonly associated with depression in women Benzodiazepines generally considered safe
GERD No data on harmful effects of either H 2 -blockers or PPIs
Misoprostol is contraindicated (can cause miscarriage, fetal death, congenital anomalies)
Calcium-containing antacids are first-line therapy
H 2 -blockers preferred over PPIs
Acne Oral isotretinoin and topical tazarotene are contraindicated owing to congenital defects Most other topical agents are considered classes B and C
Asthma Extensive data on safety of common drug categories: benefit ratios far exceed risk in treating women Glucocorticoid inhalers
Systemic prednisone for flares
Short- and long-acting bronchodilators
Seizure disorders Difficult to separate effects of medication from effects of seizure on fetal development
All agents associated with some increased risk for fetal abnormality (4-8%, compared with 1-2% in general population); valproate and phenobarbital have highest risks
Monotherapy at lowest doses recommended
Avoid medication changes in first trimester
Folate supplementation in preconception period
Hypertension (not preeclampsia) ACE inhibitors and ARBs are contraindicated in pregnancy; possibly associated with cardiovascular and neurologic anomalies in first trimester; may cause abnormalities in renal hemodynamics in third trimester
Most data suggest thiazide diuretics are safe if stable use before pregnancy
β-Blockers, especially labetalol, and methyldopa are first-line choices
Calcium-channel blockers are also considered safe
Lipid disorders Circulating lipid levels are elevated with pregnancy and breast-feeding Except in very high risk women, no medications during pregnancy; ideally, stop statins before conception
Analgesics for fever and pain management Controversy about whether NSAIDs slightly increase risk for miscarriage in first trimester Acetaminophen preferred; aspirin also considered safe
Headache Controversy about whether NSAIDs slightly increase risk for miscarriage in first trimester Acetaminophen preferred; aspirin also considered safe
Diabetes First-generation sulfonylureas contraindicated in pregnancy; may cause fetal hyperinsulinemia and birth defects Conversion to insulin during planned preconception period
Insulin, metformin, and glyburide preferred in women of childbearing potential
Autoimmune conditions Must weigh benefits of immunosuppressive use against potential risks to both mother and infant
Methotrexate is contraindicated in pregnancy because it induces
miscarriage
Limited data on TNF-alpha and IL-17 inhibitors; available data indicate minimal transfer of IgG across placenta and no known birth defects or premature birth
Prednisone generally considered safe in pregnancy
Azathioprine, sulfasalazine, cyclosporine, and hydroxychloroquine generally preferred if required
Tobacco control Cigarette smoking has known harmful effects on fetus
In several randomized controlled trials, nicotine replacement was associated with reduced levels of nicotine and improved birth outcomes
Bupropion has not shown adverse outcomes in several small randomized controlled trials
Try nonpharmacologic approaches to cessation first
Short course of nicotine replacement likely better for fetus than smoking
Polycystic ovarian disease Metformin can restore ovulatory cycles; use with contraception
Bacterial infections Tetracyclines accumulate in fetal bone and teeth
Sulfa drugs may increase risk for neural tube defects with use in first trimester and kernicterus with use in third trimester
Trimethoprim interferes with folic acid metabolism
Streptomycin and kanamycin associated with bilateral deafness
Penicillins, cephalosporins, erythromycin, azithromycin considered safe
ACE = angiotensin-converting enzyme; ARB = angiotensin receptor blocker; GERD = gastroesophageal reflux disease; IL-17 = interleukin-17; NSAID = nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug; PPI = proton pump inhibitor; SSRI = selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitor; TNF = tumor necrosis factor.

Cancer

Cancer is the leading cause of death in women ages 40 through 65 years, and it is the leading cause of years of life lost in women younger than age 65 years. Breast cancer ( Chapter 183 ) is the most common type of cancer and the second leading cause of cancer death in women. Studies indicate that many women significantly overestimate their personal risk for the disease. The lack of understanding of the cause of most breast cancers and the limitations of the imaging modalities used as screening tests have hampered efforts at breast cancer control. Data suggesting overdiagnosis of breast cancer, especially in women ages 40 to 50 years, has prompted an appreciation for the implications of screening mammography and the virtue of shared decision making, especially in this age group. After decades of an increasing incidence of breast cancer in the United States, incidence rates have fallen in the past decade. The cause of this decline is not understood; reduced use of postmenopausal hormone therapy and recent declines in screening rates have been implicated. In women who are known carriers of the BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations, estimates now can be made for age-specific risks of breast, ovarian, and contralateral breast cancer (see Chapter 183 ).

Lung cancer ( Chapter 177 ) is now the leading cause of cancer death in women, and rates continue to rise, commensurate with the timeline for increasing rates of smoking in women. Most lung cancers are smoking related, although women are more likely than men to have lung cancers that are not tobacco related. Based on the results of randomized trials, guidelines recommend low-dose chest tomographic screening of women as well as men who have a greater than a 20 pack-year smoking history, who are current smokers, or who quit within the previous 15 years. Nevertheless, smoking cessation ( Chapter 363 ) continues to be the most effective strategy to prevent lung cancer and should be the focus of primary prevention.

Colorectal cancer ( Chapter 179 ) has a similar incidence in both women and men. Screening is recommended beginning at age 45 years and continuing to age 75 years for both women and men using colonoscopy every 10 years, sigmoidoscopy every 5 years, annual stool testing with a fecal immunochemical test or every 1 to 3 years with a DNA fecal immunochemical test. Rates of screening in women are similar to men, but neither reach Healthy People 2030 goals for this effective preventive screening.

Ovarian cancer ( Chapter 184 ) is relatively rare, with about 21,000 cases in the United States, and its annual and incidence has declined in recent decades. However, mortality is high owing to its presentation at late stages in most cases. Lower abdominal or pelvic pain, urinary symptoms, and changes in bowel habits are nonspecific and common in many women, thereby limiting the ability to detect this cancer at an early stage. A screening pelvic examination is not useful in asymptomatic women, and no effective screening test has been shown to reduce mortality from ovarian cancer. As a result, screening of the general population is not recommended.

The greatest advance in cancer prevention is the development of vaccines against the most carcinogenic subtypes of human papillomavirus (HPV) associated with cervical cancer ( Chapters 184 and 344 ) and anal cancer. Although concern of tacit approval of sexual activity among young adolescents has been cited by parents as a reason to delaying vaccination, evidence does not demonstrate this concern to be founded, and vaccination is recommended for girls at ages 11 to 12 years ( Chapter 15 ). Pap test screening can be delayed until age 21 years. Cervical cancer screening is generally recommended with cervical cytology about every 3 years in women age 21 to 29 years and then either every 3 years with cytology alone or every 5 years with HPV testing in women ages 30 to 65 years. Pap tests are not recommended for women after hysterectomy for nonmalignant indications or for women older than 65 years with adequate recent screening and no high-risk factors.

You're Reading a Preview

Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles

Become membership

If you are a member. Log in here