Preanesthetic Evaluation : False-Positive Tests


Case Synopsis

A 25-year-old male athlete presents for repair of the anterior cruciate ligament of his knee. He is currently not on any medications. He has a negative personal and family history of abnormal clotting or bleeding or easy bruising. Multiple tests, including prothrombin time and partial thromboplastin time (PTT), are ordered. The PTT results are reported as above normal. The surgery is postponed, and an extensive hematology workup is performed. The final report concludes “normal variant, no coagulation defect.”

Problem Analysis

Definition

A test is useful only to the extent that clinicians (and patients) can understand the implications of a positive or negative result. Few, if any, tests always correctly identify the presence or absence of disease in all patients. Clinicians can decide what to do with a “positive” or “negative” test result only when they have a clear knowledge of the test’s characteristics and its statistical predictive value when applied to a specific patient population. Such “medical decision analysis” directly affects the clinical care of patients.

Some tests provide a qualitative binary positive or negative result. Most test results, however, are quantitative and define a range of “normal” values around a central mean. Therefore members of any population will have an “abnormal” test result but do not actually have a disease. This means that a test result may be misleading owing to natural variability in the general population.

The test can give an incorrect result due to (1) inaccuracy, (2) imprecision, or (3) incorrect performance. The accuracy of a test is the difference between the mean value of test results and the true result, as measured by a gold-standard test. The precision of a test is the reproducibility of results between instruments or persons performing the test. An incorrectly performed test may completely invalidate any result.

You're Reading a Preview

Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles

Become membership

If you are a member. Log in here