Bullous Diseases

Pathogenesis

The pathogenetic process in pemphigus is that of an organ-specific autoimmune disease. Lesional skin and usually serum demonstrate the presence of an IgG class autoantibody directed against desmoglein antigens present in normal squamous epithelium. The exact mechanism for this loss of self-tolerance is unknown, but CD4+ T cells recognize distinct epitopes of the extracellular portions of desmoglein 1 and 3, and preferentially produce T-helper type 2 (Th2) cytokines. Autoantibody production in pemphigus vulgaris and pemphigus foliaceus is polyclonal, and most antibodies in active disease are of the IgG ₄ subclass. Patients in remission who have persistent pemphigus antibodies in their serum have mainly the IgG ₁ subtype.

Several lines of evidence support the critical role of antibodies to desmogleins in the clinical acantholytic process. First, the antibody is consistently present in lesional skin and the patient’s serum. The serum autoantibody titers correlate with disease activity and there is a therapeutic response to plasmapheresis. Passive transfer of pemphigus from mothers to neonates occurs. Pemphigus antibody produces acantholysis when added to normal human skin in organ culture, and results in detachment when added to epidermal cell cultures. Further convincing evidence of the pathogenetic role of pemphigus antibody has been provided by the demonstration that IgG fraction purified from the serum of patients with pemphigus can induce a disease in neonatal mice that reproduces the clinical, histologic, and immunologic features of human pemphigus.

There are two alternative hypotheses to explain the autoantibody-mediated acantholysis: the desmoglein compensation hypothesis and the intracellular signaling hypothesis. In the desmoglein compensation hypothesis, binding of IgG to desmoglein molecules structurally disrupts epidermal cell adhesion. Desmoglein 1 (Dsg 1) expression is very low in mucosa, but it is expressed throughout the skin and increases in the more superficial layers. Desmoglein 3 (Dsg 3), by contrast, is expressed in all levels of mucosa, but only in and near the basal layer of the skin. Therefore, pemphigus foliaceus with Dsg 1 antibodies leads to superficial blistering in the skin, but no oral involvement. Pemphigus vulgaris with only Dsg 3 antibodies (mucosal-dominant pemphigus vulgaris) leads to oral erosions but minimal skin blisters. Amagai has proposed the “desmoglein compensation theory” as an explanation of this phenomenon, suggesting that Dsg 1 in the skin can “compensate” for the loss of Dsg 3 adhesion in this form of the disease. Finally, there can be no desmoglein compensation in pemphigus with both Dsg 1 and 3 antibodies (mucocutaneous pemphigus vulgaris), so acantholysis results in both skin and mucosa. Complement activation is not thought to play a role in acantholysis. The second hypothesis involves binding of IgG to the desmoglein cell surface antigen. This triggers transmembrane signaling and a series of intracellular pathways that lead to separation of the epidermal cells. These pathways are complex, but the validity of the process has been documented in vitro.

Although the stimulus for pemphigus antibody formation is unknown, the endemic nature of pemphigus foliaceus in Brazil suggests the involvement of an environmental factor, possibly an infectious agent. Most of the cases in Brazil occur in populations residing near rivers, and an insect vector for a microorganism has been proposed. Whether pemphigus in other geographic areas is precipitated by similar events is unknown. d -Penicillamine may produce pemphigus (predominantly pemphigus foliaceus) in patients being treated for rheumatoid arthritis, Wilson’s disease, scleroderma, or other penicillamine-responsive disorders. Consequently, it is likely that a variety of stimuli may give rise to epidermal antigen intolerance.

There is a strong association of pemphigus vulgaris with the HLA class II alleles HLA DRB ^∗ 0402, DRB ^∗ 0401, and DQB1 ^∗ 0503. These HLA alleles may restrict autoreactive responses to desmoglein 3.

Classification

There are two histopathologically distinct forms of pemphigus. Pemphigus vulgaris is the most severe type and is characterized histopathologically by suprabasilar cleft formation, whereas pemphigus foliaceus is less severe and is distinguished by blister formation within or just beneath the granular layer. In pemphigus vulgaris and, to a lesser extent, pemphigus foliaceus, the blister may extend into surrounding nonblistered skin by applying shearing pressure to perilesional tissue (Nikolsky’s sign).

Pemphigus vulgaris is the most common form of pemphigus and is generally seen in the fourth to sixth decades of life. It has, however, been described both in children and in the elderly. Prior to the use of corticosteroids, 50% of patients with the disease died within the first 12 months, most frequently from secondary cachexia, sepsis, and/or electrolyte imbalance. Now, with the broad utilization of immunosuppressants, the mortality is 5%.

Pemphigus vegetans is a rare variant of pemphigus vulgaris. Proliferative and verrucous lesions with surrounding pustules gradually develop from denuded bullae on intertriginous cutaneous surfaces. Such lesions were more common in the era before corticosteroid use and may represent a host response to the blistering process. Spontaneous remission is somewhat more likely in the vegetans form. Histopathologically one sees epidermal proliferation with hyperkeratosis, papillomatosis, and acantholysis with intraepidermal abscesses containing eosinophils.

Pemphigus foliaceus is generally less severe than pemphigus vulgaris. The superficial vesicles rupture easily, producing shallow erosions and crusting that clinically resemble impetigo. Clinical blistering may be totally absent. Lesions occur on the chest, back, and scalp, and may produce a seborrhea-like scaling with eventual spread to acral areas after a prolonged period. Clinically visible mucosal lesions are absent, even in advanced cases. Autoantibodies in pemphigus foliaceus are directed predominantly against desmoglein 1. Pemphigus herpetiformis is a morphologic variant of pemphigus vulgaris or pemphigus foliaceus that occurs as grouped vesicles.

Fogo selvagem is an endemic form of pemphigus foliaceus seen in Brazil. It occurs predominantly in children and young adults from poor rural areas. It is characterized by desquamation, erythroderma, and an intense burning in the sun-exposed skin, giving rise to the term fogo selvagem (“wild fire” in Portuguese). Histopathologically and immunopathologically it is indistinguishable from pemphigus foliaceus. Unlike other pemphigus variants, this condition can be seen in multiple members of a single family. There is an increased frequency of HLA-DRB1 haplotypes, DRB1 ^∗ 0404, 1402, 1406, and 1401. An environmental “second hit” is suspected but not identified. Because of the clustering of cases near rivers, Simulium black flies have been suggested as a possible vector. IgM-anti-Dsg 1 is found in a majority of fogo selvagem patients in their native environment, but is uncommon in patients with other pemphigus phenotypes and in fogo selvagem patients who move to more urban settings, further supporting a recurrent environmental antigenic exposure in the pathogenesis of this disease.

Pemphigus erythematosus (Senear–Usher’s syndrome) represents a localized variant of pemphigus foliaceus characterized by erythematous lupus-like malar dermatitis. Patients frequently manifest an abnormal antinuclear antibody test as well as the presence of pemphigus antibody. Direct immunofluorescence microscopy may show immunoglobulin and complement components along the basement membrane, as well as characteristic intercellular pemphigus antibody deposition. This disorder is believed to represent the coexistence of lupus erythematosus and pemphigus foliaceus.

IgA pemphigus comprises a recently characterized group of IgA-mediated immunobullous diseases. This entity presents as vesicopustules with neutrophils and acantholysis, most commonly affecting the axillae and groin. Oral involvement is rare. IgA pemphigus is subdivided into two histologic types: the subcorneal pustular dermatosis type with blister formation subcorneally, and the intraepidermal neutrophilic type where blisters form throughout the epidermis. The IgA pemphigus antibodies in the subcorneal pustular dermatosis type recognize desmocollin 1, whereas rare IgA pemphigus sera recognize desmoglein 1 and 3. The antigen in the intraepidermal neutrophilic form remains uncharacterized. Only 50% of patients have circulating autoantibody on indirect immunofluorescence. The subcorneal pustular dermatosis form is clinically indistinguishable from Snedden–Wilkinson’s disease and must be differentiated by immunofluorescence studies. Rarely, either form of IgA pemphigus may exhibit concomitant expression of IgG autoantibodies—so-called IgA/IgG pemphigus.

Penicillamine and angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitor therapies have been associated with a variety of autoimmune disorders, including pemphigus vulgaris and pemphigus foliaceus. Pemphigus foliaceus accounts for 70% of the penicillamine-induced cases, and pemphigus vulgaris composes the remainder. The development of pemphigus may occur with a wide range of dosages and is often a late complication of therapy. After discontinuation of penicillamine therapy approximately half the patients resolve in 4 months, whereas the other half require suppressive corticosteroid therapy over a longer period. Autoantibodies from drug-induced patients have the same antigenic specificity on a molecular level as do those from idiopathic forms of pemphigus.

Pemphigus has occurred in association with thymoma and myasthenia gravis. Pemphigus vulgaris, pemphigus foliaceus, and pemphigus erythematosus have all been noted associations. There is little, if any, concordance between the clinical activities of the coexistent disorders. The concurrence is believed to involve an underlying failure of thymic-dependent lymphocytes in suppressing autoimmune disease.

The description of paraneoplastic pemphigus (PNP) as a distinct disorder by Anhalt et al. focuses this issue in a small subgroup of patients who had a clear-cut association of pemphigus with a tumor. The patients are clinically heterogeneous and somewhat atypical. Clinical descriptions partially resemble Stevens–Johnson’s syndrome, with target lesions and painful oral lesions seen on occasion. Some patients have been described as having a papulosquamous eruption, whereas others have tense bullae. The most common associations, in descending order, are non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, chronic lymphocytic leukemia, Castleman’s disease, and solid tumors including carcinomas, sarcomas, and melanoma. Histologically, suprabasilar acantholysis has been described in some cases, whereas keratinocyte necrosis, basal cell vacuolization, interface inflammation, and even basement membrane blisters have been described in others.

The immunofluorescent pattern in paraneoplastic pemphigus is one of intercellular IgG deposition, which may be patchy and focal, and basement membrane zone IgG and complement deposition. Circulating autoantibodies bind to different tissue sources than standard pemphigus antibodies, including urinary bladder, respiratory epithelium, and desmosomal areas of myocardium and skeletal muscle. Indirect immunofluorescence to rat bladder is the most specific diagnostic tool. PNP sera react to a unique complex of antigens, which includes the plakin protein family, including desmoplakin, bullous pemphigoid antigen 1 (BPAG1), envoplakin and periplakin, and desmogleins 1 and 3. Patients with paraneoplastic pemphigus may have antibodies to one or all of these antigens, or may start with a few and with time develop antibodies to other paraneoplastic pemphigus antigens. This observed progression may represent epitope spreading.

Unique to paraneoplastic pemphigus is a large proportion of patients who develop bronchiolitis obliterans, a lethal pulmonary condition characterized by severe hypoxia, a relatively clear chest X-ray, and an association in at least one patient with IgG deposition in bronchial epithelium intracellular spaces. Because desmoplakins are present in bronchial epithelium it is possible that this pulmonary finding is autoimmune-mediated. In summary, it appears that this is an unusual mucocutaneous disorder with myriad clinicopathologic findings, some of which are not a part of any of the forms of pemphigus.

Other sporadic and poorly understood associations with pemphigus include pernicious anemia, red blood cell aplasia, rheumatoid arthritis, and lymphomatoid granulomatosis.

Differential Diagnosis

The differential diagnosis of blistering disorders of the skin ranges from a wide variety of banal dermatoses to more serious and progressive disorders such as pemphigus, bullous pemphigoid ( Fig. 16-4 ), and epidermolysis bullosa acquisita. These disorders require clinical, histopathologic, and immunopathologic evaluation for definite diagnosis. When the etiology of blistering disorders cannot be recognized, biopsy is warranted. Subsequent decisions are made on the basis of these findings. Histopathologic characteristics of potential blistering disorders that will not be discussed here in detail are listed in Table 16-1 .

Many patients with oral ulcerations of pemphigus are misdiagnosed as having aphthous stomatitis. After months to years, however, such patients typically progress to have extramucosal involvement.

Acantholysis is the hallmark of immunologically mediated pemphigus, but it may also be seen in Grover’s disease (transient acantholytic dermatosis), Darier’s disease (keratosis follicularis), and Hailey–Hailey’s disease (benign familial pemphigus). In Grover’s disease there is involvement of the trunk with pruritic papulovesicles, but no oral involvement. It is frequently precipitated by sun exposure or heat and lasts for weeks to months, although chronic cases are not uncommon.

Darier’s disease is an autosomal dominant disorder characterized by yellowish-brown crusted papules on the scalp, intertriginous areas, and seborrheic areas of the face and trunk. The disease is slowly progressive and seldom overtly bullous. Lesions are frequently perifollicular. Although acantholysis is suprabasilar, as in pemphigus vulgaris, characteristic dyskeratotic changes (corps ronds and grains) occur within the epidermis.

Hailey–Hailey’s disease (benign familial pemphigus) is an autosomal dominant disorder characterized by multiple grouped erythematous vesicles in intertriginous areas. Mucosal surfaces are usually spared. There is extensive loss of intercellular bridges, with partial coherence of cells throughout all levels of the epidermis.

The clinical pattern of these acantholytic disorders is usually distinctive from that of pemphigus. If confusion exists, direct immunofluorescence of perilesional skin is negative for IgG deposition in these disorders, whereas pemphigus patients demonstrate characteristic intercellular IgG deposition in stratified squamous epithelial tissues.

Patient Evaluation

Close examination of all mucous membranes is indicated. Oral involvement is the rule in pemphigus vulgaris, but esophageal as well as vulvar involvement may occur. Significant esophageal symptoms and even stricture may develop. Consequently, esophageal symptoms mandate endoscopy and possible biopsy. Patients presenting with blistering skin disorders that cannot be easily explained (e.g., friction blisters and contact dermatitis) require biopsy. If there is histopathologic acantholysis, biopsy of perilesional skin for direct immunofluorescence should be performed. Indirect immunofluorescence microscopy demonstrating pemphigus antibodies in the serum further confirms the diagnosis, and antibody titers typically correlate with disease activity. Disappearance of antibody from the serum frequently precedes remission.

Chest X-ray to rule out an associated thymoma and a search for clinical symptoms of myasthenia gravis is part of good clinical care, but a low yield of positive findings is to be expected. Culture of potentially infected lesions and close attention to protein loss and malnutrition are necessary in severe cases. Chest X-ray, tuberculosis skin test, complete blood count (CBC), and blood glucose determination should be undertaken prior to initiating corticosteroid or immunosuppressive therapy.

Treatment

Initial therapy of pemphigus involves complete suppression of blistering with oral prednisone (usually 1 to 2 mg/kg daily). Initial control with 3 to 4 mg/kg daily has been suggested, but in the authors’ estimation is associated with unnecessarily severe side effects. Because therapy may need to be continued for years, corticosteroid side effects become a major clinical problem. Corticosteroid sparing may be accomplished by the addition of an immunosuppressive agent, as discussed below. Immunosuppression is continued in sufficient doses to suppress blistering until serum antibody titers become negative, at which time tapering of therapy should be attempted. Follow-up biopsy for direct immunofluorescence once clinical manifestations have cleared for >6 months on treatment can predict the likelihood of remission once medications are stopped. Ratnam and Pang showed that three-quarters of patients with negative direct immunofluorescence at this stage remain in remission, and those with negative direct immunofluorescence who do recur have mild disease. In contrast, all patients with a positive follow-up direct immunofluorescence tend to relapse within 3 months of discontinuing therapy.

Systemic methotrexate (oral, intravenous, or intramuscular) can be used in dosages of 20 to 50 mg per week, but may aggravate oral ulcers. Cyclophosphamide is effective in oral dosages of 1 to 3 mg/kg/day, and oral azathioprine may be used in dosages of 1 to 3 mg/kg/day. Mycophenolate mofetil is effective alone or in combination with steroids in doses of 1 to 3 g/day. Close attention should be paid to a variety of potential side effects, including leukopenia, hepatotoxicity, teratogenesis, sterility, oral ulcers, and cystitis, depending on the specific agent used. Patients with excessive toxicity from oral corticosteroids or cyclophosphamide may have reduced side effects with monthly pulse doses.

Plasmapheresis may be useful in pemphigus patients poorly controlled on conventional therapy. Six-liter exchanges on three separate occasions over a 3-week period are necessary to lower the antibody titer significantly. Immunosuppressants such as cyclophosphamide are then necessary to maintain the improvement and prevent the rebound of antibody levels that usually follows plasmapheresis.

Intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) therapy is emerging as a promising treatment for many immune-mediated diseases. It works rapidly, and selectively lowers serum levels of pemphigus antibody. The clinical response in individual patients is variable. The concurrent administration of an immunosuppressive agent to prevent the synthesis of new antibody improves the efficacy. The dose is usually 2 g/kg/cycle, administered over 2 to 5 days. It is traditionally given in monthly cycles, but the optimal frequency of cycles is unknown. Caution needs to be taken to avoid fluid overload in elderly patients, and venous thrombosis may occur with administration.

Rituximab is a murine–human chimeric monoclonal antibody to CD20, an antigen present on B cells but not plasma cells. It is approved for use in B-cell lymphoma and is being used off-label for pemphigus and pemphigoid. Administration in a dose of 375 mg/m ² once weekly for 4 weeks rapidly reduces the peripheral B-cell count to zero and sustains this level for 6 to 12 months. Rituximab has also been used in a dosing schedule similar to its rheumatologic use or 1000 mg initially, followed by a second infusion at 2 weeks. It seems that either dosing schedule results in a similar chance of response. Clinical improvement usually occurs within days to weeks, indicating that mechanisms other than B-cell depletion may be active. Pemphigus antibodies decrease in response to therapy and complete remission may occur. The risk of fatal infection is increased, and at present it is recommended that it be reserved for severe disease unresponsive to conventional therapy.

Because of its neutrophil-mediated pathogenesis, the drug of choice for IgA pemphigus is dapsone. Doses of 100 mg/day are usually sufficient. For patients unable to tolerate dapsone, etretinate is an alternative, providing immunosuppression by interfering with neutrophil and monocyte chemotaxis.

Pathogenesis

Although the specific mechanisms responsible for blister formation in BP are not as well established as those in pemphigus, there is good evidence that IgG antibodies directed against antigens of the hemidesmosome of stratified squamous epithelium are pivotal. Perilesional skin and frequently serum from BP patients demonstrate the presence of IgG autoantibody directed against two distinct hemidesmosomal antigens: a 230-kDa glycoprotein bullous pemphigoid antigen 1 (BPAG1 or BP230) that reacts with circulating antibodies in 50% to 70% of cases, and the 180-kDa bullous pemphigoid antigen 2 (BPAG2 or BP180) with extracellular collagen-like domains that is reactive in 30% to 50% of cases. The BP antigens are normal components of the basement membrane zone, but, as is the case in pemphigus, patients become intolerant to these antigens. The HLA DQB1 ^∗ 0301 allele may be important in initial antigen processing. Autoreactive T lymphocytes producing Th1 and particularly Th2 cytokines are critically involved in the initiation of production of pathogenic autoantibodies in BP.

Antibodies to BPAG2, also known as collagen XVII, bind to a noncollagenous region of the molecule outside the cell membrane in the lamina lucida. Several points support the pathogenic role of anti-BPAG2 antibodies in BP. Firstly, passive transfer experiments in mice have resulted in blister formation when rabbit-derived antibodies to murine BPAG2 are injected. Secondly, sensitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) testing shows that BP180 antibody titers correlate with disease severity. Finally, IgG antibodies to BPAG2 in the related condition pemphigoid gestationis can cross the placenta and cause blisters in the fetuses of mothers with this disease. Passive transfer experiments in mice have produced inflammation and subepidermal blistering. Because BPAG1 is an intracytoplasmic molecule it has been suggested that anti-BPAG1 antibodies may develop secondarily after initial skin injury by anti-BPAG2 antibodies.

BPAG2 IgG antibodies are thought to cause blistering by complement and neutrophil activation. Several pieces of information support a role for complement in the pathogenesis of BP lesions. Complement deposits have been detected in vivo in the lamina lucida, and the complement membrane attack complex has been identified in involved skin. The stimulus for leukocyte attachment is activated complement components released by immune complex activation. Neutrophils are recruited by C5a-dependent pathways. Their pathogenicity is inferred by the finding that mice deficient in gelatinase-B (a neutrophil enzyme) were protected from blistering in passive transfer experiments. When neutrophils from normal mice were injected into the gelatinase-deficient mice they developed blisters.

Degranulation of mast cells mediated by complement-derived anaphylatoxins, eosinophil activation, or a direct effect of IgG antibody is responsible for the release of chemotactic factors, proteolytic enzymes, and vasoactive amines, which subsequently mediate dermoepidermal separation. IgE is emerging as an important pathogenic factor in BP. IgE antibodies against BPAG1 and BPAG2 have been detected in a high percentage of BP patients, with anti-BPAG1 IgE levels correlating with local eosinophil recruitment. SCID mice injected with an IgE-producing hybridoma directed toward the shed ectodomain of BPAG2 developed histologically evident subepidermal blisters in human skin grafts. Finally, IgE anti-BPAG2 is related to disease activity and severity.

Several reports have indicated that patients with BP may develop further blistering on exposure to ultraviolet light. The mechanism for this may be related to ultraviolet light activation of mast cells.

Classification

The term BP is generally reserved for patients demonstrating a chronic, vesiculobullous eruption involving predominantly nonmucosal surfaces. The distribution is usually widespread, with sites of predilection including the lower abdomen, inner thighs, groin, axilla, and flexural aspects of the arms and legs. BP antigen may vary in the amount distributed regionally, accounting for this classic distribution. However, 15% to 30% of patients demonstrate tense bullae limited to the pretibial area. Such cases are immunopathologically and histologically identical to BP, and no definite reason for the localized nature has been established. BP has been described in prepubertal children, but it is most common in the seventh and eighth decades of life. In the precorticosteroid era many cases resolved without treatment, although occasional patients developed aggressive and severe disease.

Some patients’ biopsy specimens demonstrate a heavy inflammatory infiltrate around dermal blood vessels, with an admixture of neutrophils, eosinophils, and mononuclear cells. The prominence of the eosinophil infiltration serves to differentiate this disorder from dermatitis herpetiformis histopathologically. The second histopathologic type is characterized by a sparse inflammatory infiltrate of mononuclear cells around superficial dermal blood vessels in the presence of prominent vesiculation in the basement membrane zone. Immunopathologic diagnosis is essential to separate this from other immunobullous diseases.

The term cicatricial pemphigoid is reserved for those forms of the disease characterized by blistering and scarring. Classically this is a disease of the elderly, involving erosions of mucosal surfaces, especially the conjunctiva ( Fig. 16-6 ), but also including the nasopharynx, oropharynx, esophagus, larynx, urethra, and anal mucosa. The morbidity and mortality of the disorder are related to the scarring produced by the recurrent lesions. Associated skin lesions occur in a minority of cases. Eye involvement may result in conjunctival symblepharon with obliteration of the conjunctival sulcus. Subsequent scarring of the cornea may produce blindness. The gingivae are commonly involved, and the disease may present only as “desquamative gingivitis.” Esophageal lesions begin as smooth-bordered erosions, but stricture may occur and require repeated dilatation. Direct immunofluorescence microscopy of mucous membrane tissue reveals IgG and/or IgA anti-BMZ antibody in more than 80% of cases. Immunofluorescent-negative cases may represent a technical problem with obtaining adequate tissue from mucosal surfaces such as the eye. However, it is important to obtain positive direct immunofluorescence results, even if multiple biopsies are required, in order to separate the disorder from pemphigus, lichen planus, and cicatrizing conjunctivitis secondary to irritants and allergens. Indirect immunofluorescence studies reveal circulating anti-BMZ antibodies of IgG or IgA class in less than 50% of cases. Antibodies in cicatricial pemphigoid recognize several BMZ molecules, including BPAG1 and -2, laminin 332, α6β4 integrin, and type VII collagen. The scarring nature of this disease may be explained by the fact that the BPAG2 antibodies in cicatricial pemphigoid recognize the distal extracellular domain (carboxy terminus) of this molecule, which ends in the lamina densa, in contrast to classic BP patients where the more proximal NC16A domain of BPAG2 is targeted.

A specific localized scarring variant of cicatricial pemphigoid has been termed the Brunsting–Perry type. In this variant, scarring and blister formation occur on the head and neck without concomitant oral involvement. The pathogenesis of cicatricial pemphigoid is believed to be similar to that of BP, although the reason for localized disease and scarring is not understood.

There have been numerous evaluations of the association between BP and internal malignancy. BP has been reported in association with malignancies of the lymphoreticular system, skin, lung, breast, pancreas, kidney, and gastrointestinal tract. However, rarely have concurrent onset or a parallel course been documented. Ahmed and coworkers, as well as Stone and Schroeter, were able to find no increased rate of malignancy in their BP patients, but a study by Chorzelski et al. did claim a 10% association. Most authors have concluded that there is no increased incidence of malignancy in BP patients compared to age-matched controls. Thus, BP is best considered not to be a cutaneous marker of internal malignancy. However, recent evaluation of a subset of 35 cicatricial pemphigoid patients who had IgG serum antibodies directed against laminin 332 found that 10 patients had an associated malignancy.

This finding gives further credence to the need to characterize individual patients’ antigen-binding profiles. Testing for specific antigen binding is only available in research laboratories at present, but indirect immunofluorescence on basement membrane split skin is a standard technique in immunopathology laboratories, and can suggest the presence of antibodies to laminin 332 on the basis of the uncommon dermal binding pattern.

BP has been reported in association with a wide variety of other disorders, including psoriasis, diabetes mellitus, lupus erythematosus, pernicious anemia, thyroiditis, polymyositis, and rheumatoid arthritis. It seems unlikely that any of these associations is important in pathogenesis, but the reasons for the associations remain unclear. In a case–control study in 1984 Chuang and associates found 20% of BP patients had diabetes, compared to 2.5% of controls. This association remained significant even after correcting for age differences. The association with rheumatoid arthritis seems to be significant, and it has been hypothesized that the two disorders may share similar pathogenetic mechanisms.

Lichen planus pemphigoides has been described on many occasions. It is characterized by the typical outbreak of lichen planus followed by a bullous eruption with the histological and immunopathological findings of BP. It is unclear whether these patients have coexistent lichen planus and BP, or whether this is a distinct entity in which the inflammatory process of lichen planus stimulates an immune response to BP antigens.

Differential Diagnosis

The initial diagnostic approach to blistering disorders is reviewed under the differential diagnosis of pemphigus. If biopsy suggests that the blister is subepidermal, direct immunofluorescence microscopy of perilesional tissue is indicated. BP characteristically demonstrates linear deposition of IgG along the basement membrane. Some cases of pemphigoid have also been described as having IgG and IgA along the basement membrane, making the separation from linear IgA bullous dermatosis somewhat arbitrary.

Dermatitis herpetiformis is differentiated by its clinical appearance (see later discussion), as well as by the characteristic deposition of granular IgA in perilesional tissue. Linear IgA bullous dermatosis shows characteristic deposition of IgA along the basement membrane as the predominant and usually the only immunoglobulin. Linear IgA disease is sensitive to sulfone therapy.

Erythema multiforme may also show a subepidermal blister. Characteristic involvement of the palms and soles with target lesions (minor type) or involvement of mucous membranes and skin (major type) in an acute fashion is characteristic of erythema multiforme. Biopsy of erythema multiforme reveals individually necrotic keratinocytes, and direct immunofluorescence fails to reveal anti-BMZ antibody. Occasionally, patients with erythema multiforme may have immunoglobulins in superficial dermal blood vessels.

Bullous lupus erythematosus usually occurs in patients who fulfill the American Rheumatism Association (ARA) criteria for systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). In addition, the disorder shows granular deposition of immunoglobulin along the BMZ. Such deposition may be sufficiently intense to give a band-like pattern that can be confused with BP. However, patients with bullous lupus erythematosus histopathologically demonstrate a neutrophilic infiltrate similar to that of dermatitis herpetiformis.

Bullous forms of lichen planus exist that are distinguished by an intense mononuclear infiltrate adjacent to the BMZ, absence of anti-BMZ antibodies, and characteristic epidermal changes of lichen planus, which allow differentiation.

Epidermolysis bullosa of the junctional and dystrophic types may show a blister at the dermoepidermal junction. Such cases are characterized by onset of blistering early in childhood, absence of the inflammatory infiltrate, and negative direct immunofluorescence. The scarring, progressive nature of these disorders is easily distinguishable clinically.

Porphyria cutanea tarda also shows pauci-inflammatory subepidermal blistering, which occurs in sun-exposed areas. Histologically, the dermal papillae irregularly extend into the bulla cavity. Direct immunofluorescence microscopy may be positive, further confusing this differentiation. The diagnosis of porphyria cutanea tarda is ultimately made on the basis of elevated 24-hour uroporphyrins. Pseudoporphyria related to the use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) may give a clinical, pathologic and immunopathologic pattern identical to that of porphyria cutanea tarda, but the 24-hour uroporphyrin level is normal. Epidermolysis bullosa acquisita is discussed in detail later.

The mucous membrane lesions of cicatricial pemphigoid must be differentiated from those of oral lichen planus, erythema multiforme, aphthous stomatitis, Behçet’s syndrome, and pemphigus. The differentiation from oral lichen planus and erythema multiforme can usually be made histopathologically. Aphthous stomatitis lesions tend to be small and punched out. Behçet’s syndrome need only be considered if other components of the syndrome, including genital ulceration, pustular dermatosis, and iritis, are present. None of these disorders demonstrates anti-BMZ antibodies.