What Are Appropriate Palliative Interventions for Patients With Advanced Dementia?


Introduction and Scope of the Problem

A growing body of literature shows that individuals with dementia receive suboptimal palliative care. Symptoms such as pain, dyspnea, and agitation are common, occurring in 40% to 50% of patients with advanced dementia. These symptoms become more common as dementia progresses and death nears. Burdensome interventions, such as hospitalizations, are commonly seen in the last months of life. Those individuals with dementia who reside in a nursing home are at further risk for the undertreatment of symptoms and interventions that offer little evidence of benefit, including the use of artificial nutrition at the end of life.

Summary of Evidence Regarding Palliative Care Interventions

Advanced dementia is the end stage of a progressive terminal illness in which individuals have significant impairments in both cognitive and functional status. Key elements of palliative care for individuals with advanced dementia include advance care planning; caregiver support; management of symptoms, including pain and dementia-related behaviors; avoidance of potentially inappropriate interventions; and counseling about hospice enrollment. Improving the delivery of these palliative interventions can significantly improve the care given to individuals with dementia and their family members. In a study by Engel and colleagues, greater satisfaction with care among decedents of nursing home residents with advanced dementia was associated with increased time spent discussing advance directives with the health care proxies, greater resident comfort, and less use of feeding tubes. Following are descriptions of key components of palliative care for people with advanced dementia and the evidence base to support them.

Advance Care Planning

One of the most important aspects when caring for patients with dementia is to plan for continued disease progression. Advance care planning should occur as early as possible in the course of the illness, preferably while patients maintain decision-making capacity for stating their values and preferences in order to help guide decisions when they become unable to speak for themselves. Specific aspects of care, such as artificial nutrition and hydration, intubation, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, and other common medical interventions at the end of life, should be explored with patients and their family members and documented in advance health care directives. Gaster and colleagues have developed a dementia-specific advance directive to help address the changes in goals of care that patients may want as the disease progresses.

Taking a step back from the specific treatments and documenting overall values and goals, including whether the patient views comfort and quality of life as an overriding priority, may be more helpful for surrogate decision makers when asked to weigh the risks and benefits of the many interventions frequently performed on patients with advanced dementia. This approach also highlights the importance of documenting a trusted designee to make decisions when an individual loses either medical or financial capacity through the use of a durable power of attorney for both health care and financial matters. At the same time, capacity is not all-or-nothing and is both decision and time specific. Patients with dementia can still participate in decision making and provide meaningful input for end-of-life preferences.

Advance care planning may be difficult in the context of dementia as many patients may not understand what living with severe dementia will look like. There is mixed evidence for using video decision aids to communicate goal-directed care for patients with dementia. In one study, family decision makers who received a goals of care video decision aid and structured care plan meeting reported better quality of communication, better end-of-life communication, and greater concordance with clinicians on goals of care. Furthermore, patients in the intervention group experienced fewer hospital transfers in addition to having more palliative care content in their treatment plans and higher use of the Physician (or Medical) Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment order set. Another study found that nursing home residents whose health care proxies watched an advance care planning video were more likely to have documented directives to forgo artificial nutrition. However, the video intervention did not have an effect on preferences for level of care, directives to withhold intravenous hydration, or burdensome treatments.

Patient preferences are often not documented early in the disease, despite the anticipated loss of capacity that occurs with dementia. One reason for this is that family members often may not realize the importance of discussing advance care plans with their loved one until it is too late to have the discussion. When talking with family members of individuals with advanced dementia, it is important to frame these decisions in the context of having a terminal illness, because family members of nursing home residents with dementia who perceive that the patient’s prognosis is poor have reduced likelihood of receiving burdensome interventions in the last three months of life.

Hospice Enrollment

Hospice services should be considered for individuals with end-stage dementia. Hospice enrollment for individuals with end-stage dementia is associated with improved patient and caregiver outcomes compared to usual care. Hospice enrollees are more likely to have better pain management and fewer hospitalizations during the last 30 days of life than those not receiving hospice services. They are more likely to receive scheduled opioids for pain and symptomatic treatment for dyspnea, as well as have fewer unmet needs during the last seven days of life. Individuals with dementia are significantly more likely to die in their location of choice and less likely to die in the hospital if enrolled in hospice. Furthermore, caregivers of individuals enrolled in hospice because of dementia also have greater satisfaction with end-of-life care.

The current National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization (NHPCO) guidelines for hospice eligibility are of limited accuracy in predicting death within six months. Nevertheless, it is important to note that effective use of hospice inevitably means that many patients who are referred will survive beyond six months and that appropriateness for hospice is not based on actual survival, but rather a reasonable expectation that survival will be less than six months if the disease follows its usual course. It would therefore be appropriate to refer to hospice individuals with advanced dementia who develop pneumonia, febrile episodes, or eating problems, because these are markers of a poor six-month prognosis.

You're Reading a Preview

Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles

Become membership

If you are a member. Log in here