Posterior Approaches to the Hip


Key Points

  • The posterior approach to the hip allows excellent exposure of the femur and acetabulum for total hip arthroplasty.

  • The extensile nature of the posterior approach makes it an important tool for primary and revision surgery.

  • Minimally invasive surgery has yet to show any clinical advantage over standard posterior approaches to the hip.

  • The posterior approach to the hip preserves the hip abductor mechanism.

  • Posterior capsular repair is associated with reduced dislocation rates, similar to those of other approaches.

The basic fundamentals of total hip arthroplasty (THA) begin with the surgical approach. A complete understanding of anatomy and the surgical approach is critical to a successful outcome. It is clear that one surgical approach may not satisfy all patients and different situations may require an alternative approach, such as extensile approaches or osteotomies. Although most surgeons choose a surgical approach based on experience and training, it is important that they be familiar with multiple exposures.

Much debate and controversy have arisen in the past decade regarding the ideal surgical approach. Surgical approaches that require specialized instruments and even modified implants have been developed. Minimally invasive surgery gained popularity by promoting less muscle damage, faster recovery, and improved clinical outcomes. To date, however, little evidence exists to support these claims, and concern continues regarding associated complications. The direct anterior approach (DAA) is now gaining attention and is touting many of the same benefits of minimally invasive surgery. Likewise, however, few data currently show the superiority of one approach over another.

This chapter focuses on the posterior approach to the hip for THA. The purpose is to review the historical background, pertinent anatomy, and surgical techniques. In addition, extensile exposures and current controversies regarding the posterior approach are reviewed.

Historical Background of the Posterior Approach to the Hip

This procedure was initially described as a surgical approach to the hip joint for the treatment of infection and war wounds. Bernhard von Langenbeck is credited with the first description in 1867 of what he termed “the longitudinal incision to the hip.” With the hip in a flexed position, he fashioned an incision “from above the ischiadic notch to the middle of the greater trochanter that reaches the joint passing between the bundles of the gluteal muscles.” Langenbeck applied this surgical approach for resection of the femoral head (what he called “hip joint resection”) and used hooks or “ball-screw” devices to extract the femoral head after cutting the ligamentum teres.

Kocher modified Langenbeck's approach by extending it in a caudal direction. He stated, “The incision is an angular (or curved) one, extending from the base of the outer surface of the great trochanter upwards to its anterior superior angle, and from thence obliquely upwards and backwards in the direction of the gluteus maximus.” Division of the gluteus maximus tendon and anterior reflection of the gluteus medius and minimus were followed by internal rotation of the hip and detachment of the piriformis and the other short external rotators. Regarding this approach, Kocher said that “it is a further development of Langenbeck's method by the oblique incision.”

Melham and associates, in their 2000 article entitled “Hyphenated-History: The Kocher-Langenbeck Surgical Approach,” stated as follows:

The Kocher-Langenbeck surgical approach continues to be widely used today by both orthopaedic trauma surgeons and reconstructive hip surgeons. By many it is considered to be a workhorse approach for posterior wall fractures of the acetabulum, femoral neck fractures treated via hemiarthroplasty, and total hip replacement. The durability of an idea born in the nineteenth century on the battlefields of Europe and refined in the operating theaters of Bern is indeed impressive. If he were around today, Kocher's humility would certainly be challenged by the widespread use of his particular portion of hyphenated-history.

Dr. Alexander Gibson and Dr. A. T. Moore are largely credited with popularization of the posterior approach, often referred to as the “Southern approach,” which is used today for THA. Although their initial description of the posterior approach has undergone several modifications since its initial description in 1950, the fundamentals of the exposure remain largely intact. Many of the modifications involve different placement and size of the skin incision, preferential detachment of the short external rotators, and posterior capsular repair. The usefulness of this approach can be appreciated by the diverse surgical procedures that can be performed through the posterior approach. These include hemiarthroplasty and total arthroplasty of the hip, hip resurfacing, open reduction and internal fixation of acetabular fractures, and arthrotomy and drainage of the hip joint for infection.

Surgical Anatomy of the Posterior Approach to the Hip

Muscular Anatomy

The muscles covering the posterior aspect of the hip joint are divided into deep and superficial layers. Henry described the outer layer as the “deltoid” muscle of the hip, similar to the deltoid of the shoulder. This layer consists of the gluteus maximus, the fascia lata, and the tensor fascia lata, which together form the outer sheath of the hip musculature ( Fig. 17.1 ).

Fig. 17.1, Illustration demonstrating the outer sheath of the hip joint muscles, including the gluteus maximus, fascia lata, and tensor fascia lata.

The deep layer of the hip encountered during the posterior approach consists of the short external rotators. From cephalad to caudad, they include the piriformis, superior gemelli, obturator internus, inferior gemelli, obturator externus, and quadratus femoris ( Fig. 17.2 ). The musculotendinous insertions of the gluteus medius and minimus insert at the tip of the greater trochanter and are not disturbed during the posterior approach to the hip. Table 17.1 lists the origins and insertions of pertinent muscles of the posterior approach along with their neurologic innervation.

Fig. 17.2, Illustration of the deep layer of the hip, which includes the short external rotators: piriformis, superior gemelli, obturator internus, inferior gemelli, obturator externus, and quadratus femoris.

TABLE 17.1
Anatomic, Functional, and Nervous Innervation of Posterior Structures of the Hip
Muscle Origin Insertion Function Innervation
Posterior ilium Iliotibial band Hip extension and external rotation Inferior gluteal nerve
Gluteus maximus Sacrum and coccyx Gluteal tuberosity
Sacrum Upper border greater trochanter Hip abduction and external rotation 1st and 2nd sacral nerves
Piriformis
Superior gemelli Inner aspect obturator foramen Medial surface greater trochanter Hip external rotation Sacral plexus
Obturator internus
Inferior gemelli
Obturator externus Upper border ischial tuberosity Linea quadrata of femur Hip external rotation Sacral plexus
Quadratus femoris
Gluteus medius Outer surface of ilium Anterior border of greater trochanter Hip abduction and internal rotation Superior gluteal nerve
Gluteus minimus

You're Reading a Preview

Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles

Become membership

If you are a member. Log in here