Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
For additional material related to the content of this chapter, please see Chapters 59 and 63 .
Emmanuel is a 14-year-old boy born with epidermolysis bullosa (EB), a rare genetic blistering skin disease, who develops acute worsening fatigue, shortness of breath, and severe cachexia with loss of 18% of his body weight. He is diagnosed with heart failure and a large left ventricular thrombus and is admitted to intensive care .
While Emmanuel had attended elementary school every day, when he moved to middle school he developed foot pain that interfered with his ability to ambulate. Three weeks ago, his weight rapidly declined and he “seemed to stop enjoying life.” He spent the majority of his time indoors watching movies, whereas previously he liked swimming in the family pool with his siblings and dog .
Emmanuel initially appears bothered by conversations regarding his prognosis. He is vigilant of his parents’ reactions to news and often makes comments such as, “I’m okay, mom. Don’t worry about me.” He apologizes when he is having a tough day. Emmanuel is reticent to express his own feelings; however, he has no history of anxiety and depression nor has he appeared sad during the current admission .
It is unclear if Emmanuel is aware of his prognosis or whether he is downplaying his feelings regarding the disease progression in an attempt to protect his family. He and his parents participate in an online EB listserve, and he has known about other children who have died. The team encourages the parents to engage with Emmanuel about the possibility that he is approaching end of life. His parents share perspectives with Emmanuel about their own mortality and extend the conversation to include him. The team empowers Emmanuel and his parents to express preferences and to listen closely to one another’s emotions and concerns. Together, the parents and team offer Emmanuel a choice to relax food and drink restrictions, explaining the potential burdens of this change. They also help him to consider options for life-prolonging interventions and symptom management. The team explores the possibility of returning home, which Emmanuel ultimately declines. He celebrates his 15th birthday in his hospital room. A few days later, his clinical condition rapidly worsens, and he becomes more somnolent. Given diminished quality of life with no pathway to recovery, the parents, supported by the team, decide to discontinue cardiac medications, and Emmanuel dies peacefully in their arms .
The process of an individual’s death is as unique as the life that precedes it and is influenced by the nature and trajectory of the illness. In this chapter we focus on the death of a child. Approaching end of life may be the result of a predictable worsening of a prolonged illness or a precipitous and unexpected deterioration. Many diseases afford long periods of relative health and life engagement, a recovery to a prior level of functioning, when the threat of death recedes from view ( ). Physical changes and symptom burden that accompany acute or worsening chronic illness exact a considerable toll on an individual’s ability to cope regardless of the life stage.
Children’s developmental level shapes both how illness impacts their evolving sense of personal identity and their understanding of death. Infants and toddlers experience death as threatened separation from loved ones. Preschool-aged children generally view death as frightening, although often as temporary and reversible. That being said, children who have experienced or witnessed illness or loss often have a precociously mature understanding of death. Visible markers of illness (e.g., dramatic changes in weight, wheelchair dependence) can lead children to question, “Am I still me?” School-aged children’s sense of self is threatened when illness limits their ability to participate in their everyday activities, and fearfulness may accompany their deepening understanding of the finality of death. For adolescents, illness thwarts typical drive toward autonomy as they find themselves increasingly reliant on parents just when they ordinarily would be negotiating their independence. As adolescents become more capable of considering existential issues in a way younger children often cannot, illness also prompts contemplation on the meaning of their life.
As some children and adolescents mourn the loss of attaining future goals, they may also express hope, even when death is imminent. Their hopes may be fairly immediate (e.g., to graduate with their class) or be steeped in the fantasy of an open future (e.g., having children). Families and clinicians can mistake the child’s fantasy life for ignorance or denial, sometimes commenting, “Doesn’t that child know he is going to die? Someone needs to tell him.” While a rigid adherence to magical beliefs for the future may signal fear and avoidance, most children live with ongoing fluctuations in hope, an adaptive process in extraordinary life circumstances.
Sibling relationships are a crucial axis within the family ( ). The questions, concerns, and fears of healthy siblings often mirror those of the dying child: All face the threatened losses of a sense of control, identity, and relationships. For siblings who are absent from the hospital setting or shielded from medical updates, lack of information or misinformation may heighten anxiety. A feeling of shame at having a “different” family, anger around diminished attention and nurturance from parents, or being expected to take on responsibilities within the household can further heighten a sibling’s distress. Despite such challenges, the bond between the healthy siblings and the ill child is an invaluable reciprocal source of support that is too often overlooked.
For parents facing their child’s illness and death, time is not only shortened, but its order is shattered. Typical tasks of parenthood are disrupted and supplanted by the exigencies of medical care. Parents stand on the precipice between what exists in the present and what is yet to come. If parenting other children, they are inevitably torn between the needs of their dying child and those of the siblings who will remain.
Research has shown that young children often want to know prognostic information, even when the outlook is poor, and parents who share do not regret doing so. Yet, this guideline is not universal. Rather, attention must be paid to the unique characteristics of each child in determining the amount and type of information to disclose ( ).
Parents often delay or avoid discussions with their children about the possibility of death. They are unsure of how to initiate such conversations and fear unleashing overwhelming emotion that they feel ill equipped to handle. They may avoid the topic in an attempt to shield their child from the family’s grief, or for fear of instilling terrifying thoughts that their child has not yet considered. Some parents worry that discussion of death may impede their child’s ability to maintain hope. They may discourage questions from the child (e.g., “You don’t need to worry about that”) or provide overly optimistic responses (e.g., “You are going to be just fine”). Yet, many children who have lived with the cumulative toll of illness and treatment have acquired an accurate understanding of their impending death long before others discuss it with them. Most basic, parents may be reluctant to discuss death with their child because they feel overwhelmed by the reality of the prognosis and are struggling to cope with their own distress. In some instances withholding information may reflect their refusal to accept death as a possible outcome for their child ( ).
Children who sense their parents’ discomfort and avoidance often refrain from discussing their illness, prognosis, or emotional response in an effort to shield their parents from additional distress ( ). Unfortunately, this mutual pretense can result in increased anxiety for both children and parents as it perpetuates silence and isolation and prevents opportunities to ask questions, express fears, and seek support. Health care providers can help to break down barriers between children and parents by modeling open-ended exploration of goals and values. Box 11.1 presents topics to explore with parents and children.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Are there family rituals or beliefs that are important to you? |
|
|
Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles
If you are a member. Log in here