Budd-Chiari syndrome and veno-occlusive disease


Among the etiologies of portal hypertension, those caused by postsinusoidal obstruction are seen infrequently by most clinicians. Nonetheless, these disease processes represent complex clinical challenges and require a thorough knowledge of the available diagnostic and treatment modalities. Included in this group are Budd-Chiari syndrome and veno-occlusive disease. The latter condition is also referred to as sinusoidal obstruction syndrome and is most often seen after myeloablation with chemotherapy or radiation therapy before hematopoietic stem cell transplant.

Budd-Chiari syndrome

Budd-Chiari syndrome (BCS) is a group of disorders caused by occlusion of the major hepatic veins, the inferior vena cava (IVC), or both at or near the level of the hepatic vein ostia. Although a brief discussion of this clinical phenomenon first appeared in a book by Budd in 1845, Lambron in 1842 is said to have reported the first case. In 1899 Chiari collected 10 cases and reported three personal cases and presented the first thorough clinicopathologic description of the syndrome, including the hypothesis that the underlying mechanism was endophlebitis of the hepatic veins. The weight of evidence, however, favors the current opinion that the primary process is usually thrombotic rather than inflammatory. Since publication of the initial description, more than 8000 cases of BCS have been described in the medical literature. In recent years the incidence has increased substantially, most likely as a result of increased awareness of BCS, improvements in diagnostic methods, and widespread use of thrombogenic agents, such as oral contraceptives. , Nevertheless, BCS remains a relatively uncommon condition. Contemporary reports place the incidence of BCS between 0.2 and 2 per 1 million population, but these numbers are not well established and show substantial regional and geographic variation.

Obstruction of hepatic venous outflow produces intense congestion of the liver and the clinical manifestations of ascites, hepatomegaly, and abdominal pain. Depending on the rapidity and extent of obstruction of hepatic venous outflow, the course of BCS may be rapid or chronic, progressing to death in weeks or leading to death from liver failure or bleeding esophageal varices after an illness of months or occasionally years. In Western countries, a rapid course is common, and the outcome is often fatal in reported cases. With prompt diagnosis and improved therapeutics, however, this condition can be managed as a chronic condition or cured entirely. Effective surgical therapy developed at highly specialized centers enables durable decompression of the obstructed hepatic vascular bed. As a result, the previously dismal outlook for patients with BCS has improved considerably. The advent of less invasive measures, notably the introduction and wide adoption of transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) and hepatic vein stent, has further reduced the morbidity related to BC (see Chapter 85 ). For patients in whom these measures fail, liver transplantation remains a viable option, with excellent results despite recurrent disease in some reports (see Chapter 105 ). Many centers have adopted a stepwise approach to treatment, converting this once uniformly fatal process to a well-controlled, manageable condition.

Predisposing conditions

Specific conditions are known to predispose to the development of BCS ( Box 86.1 ). During the past 60 years, a marked change has been observed in the frequency with which a known cause or predisposing condition has been identified in patients with BCS. In the classic collective review of 164 cases of BCS reported by Parker in 1959, a predisposing condition or etiology could not be identified in 70% of the patients. In recent years, the incidence of idiopathic cases of BCS has plummeted to less than 30%, an improvement attributed to two factors: (1) a greater awareness of BCS and (2) improved diagnostic tools to identify the anatomic lesions and to diagnose thrombogenic hematologic disorders. In fact, many experts agree that there may be multiple predisposing risk factors for the development of this syndrome.

BOX 86.1
Conditions Predisposing to Budd-Chiari Syndrome (BCS)

Primary BCS

  • Hematologic disorders

    • Polycythemia vera

    • Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria

    • Essential thrombocythemia

    • Primary erythrocytosis

    • Myelofibrosis

    • Acute leukemias and lymphomas

    • Hemolytic anemias

    • Protein C deficiency

    • Protein S deficiency

    • Antithrombin III deficiency

    • Lupus anticoagulant (antiphospholipid syndrome)

    • Factor V Leiden mutation

    • JAK2 V617F mutation

    • Prothrombin (factor II) mutation

    • Antiphospholipid syndrome

    • Hyperhomocysteinemia

  • Oral contraceptives

  • Pregnancy and postpartum

  • Connective tissue disorders

    • Behçet’s syndrome

    • Sjögren’s syndrome

    • Mixed connective tissue disease

    • Sarcoidosis

    • Rheumatoid arthritis

    • α 1 -Antitrypsin deficiency

    • Idiopathic hypereosinophilia syndrome

    • Systemic lupus erythematosus

  • Membranous obstruction of inferior vena cava

Secondary BCS

  • Malignant neoplasms

    • Hepatocellular carcinoma

    • Renal cell carcinoma

    • Adrenal carcinoma

    • Leiomyosarcoma of inferior vena cava

    • Others (carcinomas of lung, pancreas, and stomach; melanoma; reticulum cell sarcoma; adrenal sarcoma; tumor of right atrium)

  • Infections

    • Amebic liver abscess

    • Aspergillosis

    • Hydatid disease

    • Schistosomiasis

    • Syphilitic gumma

    • Filariasis

  • Trauma

  • Iatrogenic

    • Malposition/occlusion of transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt

    • Caval filter dysfunction

Regional variation in etiology between the East and West in the predisposing conditions and in the anatomic pattern of BCS has been recognized for some time ( Table 86.1 ). The classic description of BCS falls under the primary designation and is directly attributable to thrombosis at the hepatic veins. Membranous obstruction of the vena cava (MOVC) is rare in the West, but it is a frequent cause of BCS in Eastern countries such as Japan, China, and India, as well as South Africa. In the West, thrombosis of the major hepatic veins alone is substantially more common than thrombosis or occlusion of the IVC, whereas in India, China, and Japan, IVC occlusion is much more common than hepatic vein occlusion alone. In North America, the acute or subacute forms of BCS predominate, and chronic BCS is observed less frequently, whereas in the East, the reverse is observed. In the West, BCS is seldom found during pregnancy or the postpartum period, whereas in India, pregnancy is a major predisposing condition for BCS. The same difference is seen in the incidence of infections, such as hepatic amebiasis (see Chapters 45 and 71 ), which are rare in the West but are reported frequently in series of BCS from India. The use of oral contraceptives (OCs) has been frequently associated with BCS in the United States, where OC use is widespread. Finally, an important distinction in etiology regarding the prevalence of myeloproliferative disorders (MPDs) highlights additional geographic differences. A recent study from China observed that MPDs were uncommon in the BCS cohort examined, whereas this is a frequent finding in Western studies. ,

TABLE 86.1
Differences Between West and East in Predisposing Conditions and Anatomic Patterns of Budd-Chiari Syndrome (BCS)
FEATURE WEST EAST
Membranous obstruction of the IVC Rare Frequent
Hepatic vein occlusion predominates +
IVC occlusion predominates +
Acute or subacute BCS predominates +
Chronic BCS predominates +
Pregnancy/postpartum Uncommon Frequent
Infection Rare Common
Oral contraceptives Frequent Uncommon
Myeloproliferative disease Common Rare
IVC, Inferior vena cava.

Hematologic disorders

Hematologic diseases that cause vascular thrombosis are the most common conditions that predispose to BCS in North America and Western Europe. Of disorders with thrombotic tendencies, myeloproliferative diseases (MPDs) are most often associated with BCS. A review of reported cases indicates myelodysplasia as an underlying etiology in approximately half of affected patients. A recent meta-analysis of BCS studies implicates MPD in 40.9% of 1062 reported cases of BCS. Historically, polycythemia vera has been the most frequently occurring of the MPDs in BCS patients, constituting 8.5% of the cases of BCS in the collected series of Parker and 10.4% of the cases in the collected series of Mitchell et al.. However, in contemporary series the prevalence is considerably higher. In the series of 77 cases reported by Orloff et al., 31% had polycythemia vera, and its association with BCS was noted to diverge from the classic description of BCS in several ways. First, it was found more often in young adults, rather than in middle-aged and elderly patients. Second, polycythemia vera has been shown to be responsive to treatment with hydroxyurea, which should be started as soon as the disease is discovered and continued for life. Other treatments for polycythemia vera include serial phlebotomy, anagrelide, interferon alfa-2b, and ruxolitinib, recently approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Whatever treatment regimen is used, the disease runs a benign course if treated early.

Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) is another hematologic disorder associated with BCS. It was responsible for 6.7% of the cases in the collected series of Mitchell et al. and 12% of the cases in the series of Valla et al.. In all the hematologic disorders associated with hepatic vein thrombosis, but particularly in PNH, thrombosis of other splanchnic vessels and even extraabdominal vessels has been observed. When diagnosed early, PNH should be treated with eculizumab to prevent long-term sequelae.

While hematologic diagnosis has become progressively more sophisticated, many other thrombogenic conditions have been identified in BCS, including other myeloproliferative states (e.g., essential thrombocythemia, primary erythrocytosis, myelofibrosis) and thrombophilic states, such as protein C deficiency, protein S deficiency, antithrombin III deficiency, and antiphospholipid syndrome with lupus anticoagulant or anticardiolipin antibodies or both. , , Patients with the factor V Leiden mutation, which leads to activated protein C resistance, have a 5-fold to 10-fold increase in the risk of thrombosis if they are heterozygotic and a 50-fold to 100-fold increase if they are homozygotic. , , More recent evidence indicates that multiple prothrombotic factors acting concurrently are involved in a substantial percentage of patients with BCS. , Rarely, hematologic malignancies, such as acute leukemia and lymphoma, have been associated with BCS.

In 2005 identification of the underlying cause of BCS was enhanced by the discovery of a very reliable and noninvasive marker for chronic MPDs. The marker is the gain-of-function mutation V617F of the JAK2 gene. By combining identification of this marker with results of bone marrow histology and clonality assay, more than 50% of BCS cases have been found to be caused by an underlying chronic MPD.

It cannot be overemphasized that every patient found to have BCS should undergo a thorough hematologic evaluation. The assessment is an expansion of the workup proposed by Mahmoud and Elias and others , ( Box 86.2 ). With these studies, it should be possible to diagnose all the known predisposing thrombogenic hematologic disorders associated with BCS. If this evaluation is uniformly performed, the incidence of idiopathic BCS will likely continue to decline.

BOX 86.2
PNH, Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria.
Screening for Hematologic Disorders in Budd-Chiari Syndrome

  • Complete blood count, prothrombin time, partial thromboplastin time, fibrinogen

  • Red blood cell mass, plasma volume

  • Bone marrow biopsy, cell culture, karyotype

  • JAK2 gene, V617F mutation in peripheral blood granulocytes

  • Antithrombin III assay

  • Protein C assay

  • Free protein S antigen assay

  • Lupus anticoagulant

  • Anticardiolipin antibodies

  • Ham’s acid hemolysis test

  • Activated protein C resistance or factor V Leiden mutation or both

  • Endogenous erythroid colony assay

  • Flow cytometry for blood cells deficient in CD55 and CD59 (PNH)

  • Molecular test for G20210A prothrombin gene mutation

  • Anti–β 2 -glycoprotein-1 antibodies

  • Plasma homocysteine level

  • β-Human chorionic gonadotropin pregnancy screen

Oral contraceptives

An increased incidence of thromboembolic phenomena involving various blood vessels and organs in women taking OCs has been well established. The first case of BCS associated with OC use was reported by Ecker and McKittrick, 5 years after these drugs became available commercially. Since then, more than 200 cases of BCS in patients taking OCs have been described, , , , , and the increasing overall incidence of BCS in recent years has been attributed partly to the widespread use of these agents. In the collective review reported by Mitchell et al., use of OCs was believed to be responsible for 9.4% of BCS cases from 1960 to 1980. Valla et al. reported a relative risk of 2.37 for hepatic vein thrombosis among OC users, similar to that of cerebrovascular accident (stroke), myocardial infarction, and venous thromboembolism. Recent literature, however, has questioned the strength of the association between OCs and venous thrombotic disease. It has been proposed that OCs are not a primary cause of BCS but contribute to thrombosis only if there is an underlying hematologic disorder. In addition to causing BCS, OCs have been linked to other liver disorders, including veno-occlusive disease, portal vein thrombosis, cholestasis, hepatocellular adenoma, and possibly hepatocellular carcinoma and angiosarcoma. ,

Pregnancy and postpartum

Budd-Chiari syndrome has been observed in women during pregnancy and, more often, during the postpartum period. The first case of BCS reported by Chiari occurred in a woman who developed the disorder after childbirth. In the collective review by Mitchell et al., 9.9% of BCS cases occurred during pregnancy or postpartum, and in a series of 105 patients with BCS observed from 1963 through 1978, Khuroo and Datta reported 16 patients (15.2%) with BCS after pregnancy; 8 patients died, and 7 were lost to follow-up after discharge. The hypercoagulable state that is known to occur during pregnancy is presumed to be responsible for the association with BCS, although only 1 of 77 cases of BCS occurred peripartum in a recently reported large series. As with OCs, it is increasingly clear that many patients in whom BCS develops in association with pregnancy may also have an underlying thrombophilia, either inherited or acquired.

Malignant neoplasms

Occlusion of the suprahepatic IVC by invasive tumors has been the cause of BCS in numerous case reports. This etiology represents prototypical secondary BCS. The most common cancers associated with BCS are hepatocellular carcinoma (see Chapter 89 ), renal cell carcinoma, adrenal carcinoma, and leiomyosarcoma of the IVC. An example of a cholangiocarcinoma occluding the intrahepatic portion of the IVC is shown in Fig. 86.1 A. Other malignancies that have been infrequently associated with BCS include carcinomas of the lung, pancreas, and stomach; melanoma; reticulum cell sarcoma; adrenal sarcoma; and sarcoma of the right atrium.

FIGURE 86.1, Axial (A) and coronal (B) magnetic resonance images demonstrate leiomyosarcoma (white arrows) of the intrahepatic inferior vena cava (white arrowhead) with nonopacification of the obstructed right hepatic vein (see Chapters 14 and 15 ).

Infections

Infections involving the liver were believed to be responsible for 3% of BCS cases reviewed by Parker, 9.9% of the cases reported by Mitchell et al., and none of the cases in sizable series reported in more recent years. The most common infections associated with BCS are those caused by parasites, particularly amebic liver abscesses, hydatid disease, and schistosomiasis (see Chapters 73 and 74 ). Syphilitic gumma of the liver accounted for 1.8% of BCS cases in Parker’s review but has not been reported as a cause of BCS in recent years. Aspergillosis involving the hepatic veins and IVC has been a rare cause of BCS. In India, Victor et al. provided evidence that filariasis can cause BCS. These cases represent rare entities that are infrequently reported in BCS literature, but may be more prevalent than reported in developing countries where health reporting is limited.

Trauma

Abdominal trauma may in particular circumstances predispose patients to the development of BCS (see Chapter 113 ). Trauma was responsible for 1.2% of BCS cases reported by Parker and 2.4% of the cases reviewed by Mitchell et al.. Blunt and penetrating trauma have been implicated occasionally in BCS patients, in whom severe liver injury leads to deep laceration at the level of the hepatic veins. Endothelial injury at this location can lead to thrombosis, scar, and ultimately the development of BCS.

Connective tissue disorders

Occasional cases of BCS have been reported in association with various connective tissue and autoimmune diseases, most of which are known to have thrombotic tendencies, including Behçet’s disease, Sjögren’s syndrome, mixed connective tissue disease, sarcoidosis, and rheumatoid arthritis. Numerous cases of BCS in patients with Behçet’s disease have been described. , A recent large series examining vascular complications in 5970 patients with Behçet’s disease reported BCS in 2.4% of the 882 affected patients. Median time from diagnosis to development of BCS was 2.3 years.

Membranous obstruction of the vena cava (MOVC)

More than 600 cases of BCS resulting from MOVC have been reported from Japan, China and other parts of Asia, India, and South Africa. In the United States and Europe, MOVC is rare. A congenital cause of this condition has been proposed, but evidence strongly suggests it represents the end result of acquired thrombosis. , ,

MOVC usually runs a chronic course during many years, and extensive hepatic fibrosis or cirrhosis and portal hypertension will have developed in most patients by the time they come to medical attention. An increased incidence of hepatocellular carcinoma has been observed in association with MOVC. , The therapeutic implications of this condition and other forms of IVC occlusion are distinctly different from those of occlusion confined to the major hepatic veins.

Miscellaneous rare conditions

Other conditions that have been rarely associated with BCS include inflammatory bowel disease, hepatic torsion after partial resection of the liver, live-donor liver transplantation of the left lateral section, lipoid nephrosis, and protein-losing enteropathy. The latter two conditions are associated with a prothrombotic condition that may predispose patients to BCS.

Pathology

The liver receives approximately one-fourth of the cardiac output through its dual afferent blood supply: the portal vein and hepatic artery. After perfusing the sinusoids, the blood is returned to the heart through the hepatic veins and IVC. Obstruction to the egress of blood from the liver at any point along the outflow route results in numerous serious hemodynamic and morphologic alterations. There is a marked increase in intrahepatic pressure, which is reflected by a similar increase in portal pressure (see Chapters 5 and 74 ). The increased intrahepatic pressure causes extravasation of plasma from the liver sinusoids and lymphatics with formation of ascites (see Chapter 79 ). Obstruction to the egress of blood from the liver also results in dilation of the sinusoids and intense centrilobular congestion of the hepatic parenchyma, which is greatest around the terminal hepatic venules (central veins) ( Fig. 86.2 ). Ischemia, pressure necrosis, and atrophy of the parenchymal cells in the center of the liver lobule are apparent. With persistence of the obstruction, the necrotic parenchyma is replaced by fibrous tissue and regenerating nodules of liver tissue. The end result is cirrhosis of the type associated with chronic congestive heart failure, often referred to as congestive hepatopathy. The rapidity with which cirrhosis develops is related to the severity of outflow obstruction, but it is not unusual for cirrhosis to occur within months. This pathophysiology is similar to that seen after liver transplantation in the patient with anastomotic venous outflow obstruction, with similar clinical manifestations.

FIGURE 86.2, Liver biopsy demonstrating typical characteristics of venous outflow obstruction under low (A) and high (B) power. Note the marked sinusoidal congestion (black arrowhead) and hepatocyte atrophy (black arrow) (see Chapter 74 ).

The reversibility of liver damage in BCS is a direct function of the extent and duration of hepatic venous outflow obstruction. Early in the course of the disease, relief of the obstruction can be expected to result in reversal of the parenchymal and hemodynamic abnormalities. Late in the course, the damage to the hepatic parenchyma becomes irreversible; thus the timing of therapy has profound implications for the prognosis.

Three major hepatic veins—the right, left, and middle—conduct blood into the IVC from the bulk of the hepatic parenchyma. The left and middle hepatic veins usually form a common trunk just before joining the IVC, and several small hepatic veins, often termed short hepatic veins, enter directly into the retrohepatic IVC and drain the caudate lobe and small central regions of the right and left lobes of the liver (see Chapter 2 ). Initially, occlusion is limited to one or two of the major veins. During variable intervals, all three of the major hepatic veins become occluded. The small hepatic veins that join the retrohepatic IVC, particularly the veins draining the caudate lobe, often are spared. These veins ultimately form the basis for intrahepatic shunts because they are the only site for adequate parenchymal drainage.

In most patients with BCS, occlusion of the hepatic veins is caused by thrombosis. The thrombus undergoes organization and ultimately is converted to fibrous tissue that permanently occludes the veins. Although recanalization of the occluded veins sometimes occurs, it rarely results in effective new outflow channels. Indeed, chronic congestion of the liver leads to some degree of irreversible parenchymal injury. Retrograde propagation of the thrombus into smaller hepatic veins is typically found. Prograde propagation of the thrombus from the hepatic veins into the IVC, with partial or complete occlusion of the IVC, sometimes occurs and greatly changes the therapeutic approach and prognosis. With the use of imaging studies (e.g., angiography) and portosystemic pressure measurements, it is important to determine whether the IVC has become involved in the occlusive process.

In membranous obstruction of the IVC, the “membrane” varies from very thin to several centimeters thick and usually contains fibrous tissue, smooth muscle, and elastic tissue. The location and extent of the membrane vary considerably, and in some cases a long segment of IVC has been replaced by fibrous tissue. Occlusion of one or more of the major hepatic veins often has been associated with membranous obstruction of the IVC. MOVC has been reported to be the most common cause of BCS in Japan, , , , India, and China, , and in the Bantu population of South Africa. Although some experienced authors have proposed a congenital cause, , , , , a strong argument has been made that suggests MOVC is the end result of thrombosis of the IVC, often occurring early in life. Most of the cases have run a chronic course before discovery, and when first seen by a physician, patients have extensive hepatic fibrosis or cirrhosis with portal hypertension and all its manifestations. The therapeutic considerations in patients with MOVC differ from those in patients with BCS caused by obstruction of the hepatic veins.

Clinical manifestations

The clinical manifestations and course of BCS are determined by the extent of occlusion of the hepatic venous outflow system and the rapidity with which the venous occlusion becomes complete. Patients can have an acute or subacute course (typical for patients in Western countries), with rapid progression of liver disease and its consequences during a few weeks to a few months. In some patients, however, BCS develops insidiously, with clinical manifestations appearing gradually during months or years. Patients with MOVC observed in Japan, China, India, and South Africa often come to the physician for the first time with manifestations of well-established cirrhosis after tolerating symptoms for many years. The chronic form of BCS, regardless of etiology, is characterized by portal hypertension and its clinical sequelae.

In 77 patients reported by Orloff et al., 12 were referred with advanced cirrhosis, and the remaining 65 patients were referred at a mean 14 weeks after onset of BCS (range, 4–78 weeks). Of the 65 patients, 59 (91%) were referred at less than 18 weeks after onset of symptoms, relatively early in the course of BCS. However, in another contemporary single-center experience, most patients presented with advanced disease at diagnosis, with 92% exhibiting ascites and 55% with cirrhosis. In the collected series of Mitchell et al., which excluded patients with MOVC, two-thirds had symptoms for less than 3 months and 83% had symptoms for 6 months or less at diagnosis. In his collected series of 133 patients, Parker observed that 57% had symptoms for 3 months or less, and 71% had been symptomatic for 6 months or less.

You're Reading a Preview

Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles

Become membership

If you are a member. Log in here