Papilloma and Papillary Lesions


Papillary lesions of the breast encompass a heterogeneous group of epithelial lesions ranging from benign to malignant, and represent one of the most challenging diagnostic entities in breast pathology, constituting 21% of pathologist-initiated second-opinion referrals. Although their exact incidence is difficult to determine with accuracy given variable terminologies used over time, papillomas account for 8% to 10% of benign breast lesions and the incidence of papillary lesions is approximately 2% overall. This chapter focuses on the more commonly encountered benign intraductal papilloma and its differential diagnosis: papillary ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS), encapsulated (intracystic) papillary carcinoma, and solid papillary carcinoma in situ.

Papilloma

Papillomas are defined as discrete benign lesions arising from the epithelium of mammary ducts that display a papillary architecture. They may be divided into two types based on location, central and peripheral, with accompanying location-specific clinical presentations, imaging characteristics, and treatment implications. Papillomas should be distinguished from papillomatosis, which traditionally refers to multifocal ductal epithelial hyperplasia.

Clinical Presentation

Papillomas of the breast can be divided into central and peripheral papillomas. Central papillomas arise in the main lactiferous ducts of the breast in the subareolar region. They may be solitary or, less often, multiple and typically arise in perimenopausal and postmenopausal women, although they have been reported in up to 5% of childhood females presenting with a breast mass. Up to 90% of patients will present with serous or serosanguineous discharge, with the remaining patients presenting with mammographic abnormalities or, less commonly, a palpable mass. Nipple discharge resulting from an underlying papilloma is generally unilateral and hemorrhagic. These lesions are typically less than 1 cm but may be as large as 4 or 5 cm.

Peripheral papillomas have a greater tendency than central papillomas to be multiple and, in fact, peripheral papillomas is a term customarily used by some as synonymous with multiple papillomas . Unlike central papillomas, peripheral papillomas most commonly present as mammographic abnormalities, often with associated calcifications. Microscopic papillomas (1–2 mm) have been referred to as micropapillomas.

In a 1951 study of 108 patients with diagnosed papillomas, 75% of the papillomas were reported to be centrally located. Although data regarding the exact distribution of central and peripheral papillomas are lacking, with the establishment of widespread mammographic screening in the early 1980s peripheral papillomas have been found to be likely as common as or perhaps more prevalent than central papillomas.

Clinical Imaging

Central papillomas are often mammographically occult, although they may appear as a circumscribed subareolar mass with well-defined borders and a lack of stromal distortion. Sonography and/or ductography are the most useful radiographic modalities for visualization of these lesions. Ultrasonography will demonstrate an intraductal mass with an associated dilated duct, a solid mass, or a complex cystic lesion ( Fig. 13.1A to C ). In a study of 51 solitary papillomas, ductograms were positive in 91% of patients and showed a completely obstructing lesion, ductal expansion and distortion, intraductal filling defects, duct ectasia, or wall irregularity.

Fig. 13.1, ( A ) Ultrasonography of a central papilloma demonstrates an intraductal mass with an associated dilated duct. ( B and C ) An unusual case of a large intraductal papilloma on mammography performed for a palpable lump. Histological sections demonstrated a prominent fibrotic capsule.

Peripheral (multiple) papillomas, as noted previously, unlike central papillomas, commonly present as mammographic abnormalities, although they may be radiographically occult ( Fig. 13.2 ). In a study by Rizzo and coworkers, 84% of patients with a diagnosis of papilloma on core needle biopsy presented with mammographic abnormalities and were otherwise asymptomatic. Calcifications are seen in at least 25% of cases.

Key Clinical Features

Intraductal Papilloma

  • Definition: Discrete benign intraductal tumoral masses composed of fibrovascular cores supporting papillary fronds.

  • Incidence/location: Papillomas represent approximately 8% to 10% of benign breast tumors and may be located centrally or peripherally.

  • Clinical features: Most common in perimenopausal and postmenopausal women, with central papillomas most often associated with symptomatic nipple discharge, whereas peripheral papillomas present as mammographic abnormalities in asymptomatic patients.

  • Imaging features: Central papillomas are usually mammographically occult but well visualized by ultrasound and/or ductography, which demonstrates a central, subareolar intraductal mass with an associated dilated duct. Peripheral papillomas present as mammographic abnormalities, commonly in association with microcalcifications.

  • Prognosis/treatment: Follow-up excisional biopsy of benign papillomas on core biopsy is controversial; close clinical and/or imaging follow-up, at a minimum, is generally recommended, although excision is common including via vacuum-assisted devices. Central papillomas are commonly completely excised to abolish symptoms; peripheral papillomas may be excised to rule out associated atypia in surrounding tissue, or if there is radiological discordance.

Fig. 13.2, Specimen radiograph of an excised papilloma shows a radiodense mass with an associated biopsy clip.

Gross Pathology

Intraductal papillomas may be grossly occult. Papillomas that are grossly identifiable are often central, involving a large subareolar duct, and appear as a mass within a dilated duct. Subareolar intraductal papillomas can be up to 3 to 4 cm in greatest dimension, although the dimensions of such larger lesions are often attributable to the dilated duct itself rather than the papilloma. Preexcisional core biopsy can particularly result in enlargement of the mass attributable to hemorrhage and/or necrosis ( Fig. 13.3 ).

Fig. 13.3, Gross photograph of an intraductal papilloma. The lesion shows a cystically dilated duct with a papillary excrescence arising from the wall; hemorrhage is present as a result of a previous core biopsy.

You're Reading a Preview

Become a Clinical Tree membership for Full access and enjoy Unlimited articles

Become membership

If you are a member. Log in here